Soteriology Compared Support
Compare

Systems of salvation

Calvinism, Arminianism and the other named systems tie several debates together. Each card shows how a system answers the five questions that define it, and which traditions hold it.

These are comparison labels; several traditions describe themselves in other terms.

The five questions side by side

SystemOriginal Sin and Human NatureFree Will and PredestinationCan Salvation Be Lost?For Whom Did Christ Die?Can Grace Be Resisted?
Calvinism (Reformed theology)Inherited guilt, total depravityUnconditional electionElect will persevereFor the electEffectual calling
ArminianismFallen, prevenient graceConditional electionLost and restored / Lost if faith diesFor all, received by faithEnabling, resistible
Lutheran theology of graceInherited guilt, total depravitySingle predestinationLost if faith diesFor all, received by faithMonergistic, resistible
Amyraldism (hypothetical universalism)Inherited guilt, total depravityUnconditional electionElect will persevereFor all, intended for the electEffectual calling
Provisionism (Traditionalist Baptist)Personal guilt onlyConditional electionElect will persevere / Eternal security (OSAS)For all, received by faithGospel enables
Thomism (Catholic school)Original sin, washed in baptismSynergy / Unconditional electionLost and restoredFor all, received by faithCooperating grace
Molinism (middle knowledge)Original sin, washed in baptismSynergyLost and restoredFor all, received by faithCooperating grace
Eastern Orthodox synergyAncestral sinSynergyLost and restoredFor all, received by faithCooperating grace
Corporate election (Restorationist)Personal guilt onlyConditional electionLost and restoredFor all, received by faithGospel enables

The systems

Calvinism (Reformed theology)

God's sovereign grace saves from start to finish. Fallen people cannot turn to God on their own; God chose the elect unconditionally, Christ died to secure their salvation, the Spirit's call brings them to faith, and God keeps them to the end. Popularly summarised by the later acronym , after the five heads of doctrine of the Canons of Dort (1619), within a wider covenant theology.

What did humanity inherit from Adam?Inherited guilt, total depravity
Does God choose who is saved, or do people choose God?Unconditional election
Is the believer secure forever, or can they fall away?Elect will persevere
Did Christ die to save the elect only, or for every person?For the elect
When God calls a sinner to salvation, can that grace be refused?Effectual calling
Reformed (holds it)Baptist (divided)Anglican (divided)Presbyterian and Reformed churches, Calvinist (Reformed) Baptists, many evangelicals

Arminianism

God's grace goes first and enables every person to respond, but it can be resisted. God elects those he foresees will believe, Christ died for all, and believers must continue in faith. Named after Jacobus Arminius and set out in the Remonstrance (1610). Wesleyan Arminians hold that the fallen can be restored; Reformed Arminians (such as Free Will Baptists) hold that apostasy cannot be undone.

What did humanity inherit from Adam?Fallen, prevenient grace
Does God choose who is saved, or do people choose God?Conditional election
Is the believer secure forever, or can they fall away?Lost and restored / Lost if faith dies
Did Christ die to save the elect only, or for every person?For all, received by faith
When God calls a sinner to salvation, can that grace be refused?Enabling, resistible
Methodist / Wesleyan (holds it)Pentecostal (holds it)Adventist (holds it)Oneness Pentecostal (holds it)Quaker (holds it)Baptist (divided)Anglican (divided)Free Will Baptists (Reformed Arminians) and General Baptists; Nazarenes and the Holiness movement (Wesleyan family)

Lutheran theology of grace

Neither Calvinist nor Arminian. Salvation is by grace alone: God alone converts, through Word and sacrament, and he elects to salvation only, never to damnation. Yet grace can be resisted and faith can be lost. Lutherans hold both sides as Scripture gives them and refuse to resolve the tension with a system (Formula of Concord, Articles II and XI).

What did humanity inherit from Adam?Inherited guilt, total depravity
Does God choose who is saved, or do people choose God?Single predestination
Is the believer secure forever, or can they fall away?Lost if faith dies
Did Christ die to save the elect only, or for every person?For all, received by faith
When God calls a sinner to salvation, can that grace be refused?Monergistic, resistible

Amyraldism (hypothetical universalism)

A modified Calvinism: Christ died for all on the condition of faith, so the gospel is offered to everyone in good faith, but God gives faith only to the elect, whom he chose unconditionally. Sometimes called four-point Calvinism. Amyraut was tried but not condemned by the French Reformed synods; most confessional Reformed theologians reject the view.

What did humanity inherit from Adam?Inherited guilt, total depravity
Does God choose who is saved, or do people choose God?Unconditional election
Is the believer secure forever, or can they fall away?Elect will persevere
Did Christ die to save the elect only, or for every person?For all, intended for the elect
When God calls a sinner to salvation, can that grace be refused?Effectual calling
Moïse Amyraut and the school of Saumur; some Reformed Anglicans (John Davenant); some evangelicals today

Provisionism (Traditionalist Baptist)

Christ's death provides salvation for every person, and the Holy Spirit draws people through the gospel itself, which can be resisted, with no regeneration or special enabling grace before faith. People inherit a nature and environment inclined toward sin, but are not guilty before they personally sin. Set out in 'A Statement of the Traditional Southern Baptist Understanding of God's Plan of Salvation' (2012), an unofficial statement signed by Southern Baptist leaders, which affirms eternal security and denies that apostasy is possible. 'Provisionism' is a later label that not every Traditionalist uses.

What did humanity inherit from Adam?Personal guilt only
Does God choose who is saved, or do people choose God?Conditional election
Is the believer secure forever, or can they fall away?Elect will persevere / Eternal security (OSAS)
Did Christ die to save the elect only, or for every person?For all, received by faith
When God calls a sinner to salvation, can that grace be refused?Gospel enables
Baptist (divided)Many Southern Baptists; Leighton Flowers

Thomism (Catholic school)

A school within Catholic teaching, following Thomas Aquinas as developed by Domingo Báñez: God predestines the saved to glory and gives grace that is effective in itself, moving the will infallibly yet freely. Sufficient grace can be resisted; efficacious grace infallibly reaches its effect, yet does not take away the will's power to dissent. The Church allows this view and Molinism, and has not ruled between them (1607).

What did humanity inherit from Adam?Original sin, washed in baptism
Does God choose who is saved, or do people choose God?Synergy / Unconditional election
Is the believer secure forever, or can they fall away?Lost and restored
Did Christ die to save the elect only, or for every person?For all, received by faith
When God calls a sinner to salvation, can that grace be refused?Cooperating grace

Molinism (middle knowledge)

A school within Catholic teaching, from Luis de Molina's Concordia (1588): God knows what every free person would do in every possible situation and chooses the world in which his plan is fulfilled through their free choices. God gives grace in circumstances where he foreknew the person would freely accept it, so its effectiveness depends on that free consent. Some Protestant philosophers also hold it.

What did humanity inherit from Adam?Original sin, washed in baptism
Does God choose who is saved, or do people choose God?Synergy
Is the believer secure forever, or can they fall away?Lost and restored
Did Christ die to save the elect only, or for every person?For all, received by faith
When God calls a sinner to salvation, can that grace be refused?Cooperating grace
Catholic (a school within it)Some Protestant philosophers (William Lane Craig)

Eastern Orthodox synergy

Salvation is theosis, union with God, in which God's grace and human freedom work together, lived in the Church and its Mysteries. Humanity inherited mortality and a weakened nature from Adam, not his guilt. Christ died for all, God forces no one, and a person can turn away and return. The Orthodox do not frame this in Western terms and reject both Calvinist and Arminian labels.

What did humanity inherit from Adam?Ancestral sin
Does God choose who is saved, or do people choose God?Synergy
Is the believer secure forever, or can they fall away?Lost and restored
Did Christ die to save the elect only, or for every person?For all, received by faith
When God calls a sinner to salvation, can that grace be refused?Cooperating grace

Corporate election (Restorationist)

God chose a people, the church in Christ, and anyone becomes one of the elect by obeying the gospel: hearing, believing, repenting, confessing Christ and being baptized. Children are born innocent, Christ died for all, the gospel itself enables faith, and a Christian can fall away. Typical of the Churches of Christ.

What did humanity inherit from Adam?Personal guilt only
Does God choose who is saved, or do people choose God?Conditional election
Is the believer secure forever, or can they fall away?Lost and restored
Did Christ die to save the elect only, or for every person?For all, received by faith
When God calls a sinner to salvation, can that grace be refused?Gospel enables

Traditions that use none of these labels

Latter-day Saints: Latter-day Saints do not use these labels. They teach agency from a premortal life, an Atonement that resurrects all, and exaltation through covenants and enduring to the end.

Jehovah's Witnesses: Jehovah's Witnesses do not use these labels. They teach that Jesus' ransom opens everlasting life to all who exercise faith and remain faithful, including through the final test at the end of the Thousand Years.

Historical positions

Rejected by the early church and by all fifteen traditions on this site. They are shown as boundary markers, and the quiz never assigns them.

Semi-Pelagianism

The view, debated in fifth-century Gaul, that the first movement toward God, the beginning of faith, comes from the person, and grace then helps. Rejected by the Council of Orange (529). Every tradition on this site rejects it; the label is sometimes thrown at opponents and should be used with care. The Orthodox reject it when it is applied to Eastern teaching on synergy, such as that of St John Cassian.

Pelagianism

The teaching linked to Pelagius (c. 354–418): Adam's sin harmed only himself, and people can obey God and earn salvation by their own natural powers, with grace only as outward help. Condemned by the Council of Carthage (418) and opposed by Augustine. Every tradition on this site rejects it.