Anglican: Article X teaches that no one can turn to God "by our own natural strength and good works" unless God's grace goes before us ("preventing us") and works with us, for it is God who works in us both to will and to do . Reformed Anglicans hold that this calling is effectual; Arminian Anglicans hold that it can be resisted, as when people resist the Holy Spirit ; Anglo-Catholics speak of grace that goes before the will and then works with it.
Baptist: Baptists are divided, and the Baptist Faith and Message does not settle the question. Calvinist Baptists hold effectual calling (1689 Confession ch. 10), because all whom the Father gives to Christ will come to him . Free Will Baptists hold resistible enabling grace, and many Southern Baptists (signers of the unofficial 2012 "Traditional Statement", sometimes called Provisionists) hold that the Spirit draws people through the gospel itself, which people can refuse as Jerusalem was not willing .
Mennonite: Yes, grace can be refused. Anabaptists teach that God, through his Word preached to all, restores the will's freedom to answer in faith and obedience, and that this call can be refused, just as Jesus wanted to gather Jerusalem but they were not willing (Balthasar Hubmaier, On the Freedom of the Will, 1527). Mennonites speak of yieldedness (Gelassenheit) and discipleship rather than Arminian categories.
Latter-day Saints: Yes, grace can be refused, because God invites and never forces, and each person must choose this day whom they will serve . The Light of Christ is given to every person to know good from evil (Moroni 7:16), the true light that enlightens everyone , and agency is central to the plan (2 Nephi 2:27). Latter-day Saints do not use the term "prevenient grace".
Jehovah's Witnesses: Yes, God's call can be refused: Jehovah draws people through his holy spirit and the Bible's message, as Jesus said no one comes to him unless the Father draws him , but each person chooses whether to respond, since anyone who wishes may take the water of life freely . Witnesses do not use the categories of this debate.
The Spirit's inward call to the elect does not fail, because it renews the will so that it comes freely (Westminster Confession 10.1; Canons of Dort III/IV.11–12, 16). Jesus says no one can come to him unless the Father draws him , and all the Father gives him will come . God gives a new heart , as when he opened Lydia's heart to respond , and those he called he also justified and glorified . Even faith itself is granted . See and .
Objection
Arminian critics point out that Stephen says you always resist the Holy Spirit , and Jesus wept over Jerusalem: how often I would have gathered your children, and you were not willing . A grace that cannot be refused seems to override the will.
Response
The outward call of the gospel is resisted every day; the inward, effectual call is not. It does not force an unwilling person but makes the person willing, as a dead man raised does not resist life .
God's grace goes first, because fallen people cannot turn to God by their own strength, and it reaches everyone: Christ, lifted up, draws all people ; the grace of God has appeared, bringing salvation to all ; the true light gives light to everyone . This grace frees the will to respond, but it can be refused. Stephen told his hearers, you always resist the Holy Spirit , and Jesus said of Jerusalem, I would have gathered you, and you were not willing . See .
Objection
Calvinists object that if everyone receives the same enabling grace, the difference between the saved and the lost is finally the person's own choice, which gives them something to boast about. They also cite Jesus' words that no one can come to him unless the Father draws him .
Response
Receiving a gift is not earning it, and faith is the opposite of boasting . The Father's drawing in John 6:44 is the grace given to all: the drawing of all people that Jesus promises .
Methodist / Wesleyan: Article VIII of the Methodist Articles of Religion teaches that without the grace of God by Christ going before us ("preventing us") we cannot turn to God. That grace has appeared to all people , but it can be refused, as Stephen told his hearers that they always resist the Holy Spirit .
Pentecostal: Pentecostals usually describe this as the Holy Spirit's convicting work and the drawing of all people that Jesus promised , rather than using the term "prevenient grace". This work can be refused, as Stephen told his hearers that they always resist the Holy Spirit .
Adventist: Adventists teach that the Holy Spirit draws and convicts every person, as Christ promised that when lifted up he would draw all people to himself , and that saving faith is God's gift through the Word. Grace can be refused, because God does not force the will: Christ stands at the door and knocks, and enters only if someone opens .
Oneness Pentecostal: God draws every person through the preached Word and the Spirit's conviction of sin , as Jesus promised that once lifted up he would draw all people to himself . Anyone may resist that drawing, and anyone may respond by obeying the apostolic message . Oneness Pentecostals rarely use the term "prevenient grace".
Quaker: Friends speak of the Light of Christ given to every person , the grace that has appeared to all people , which enlightens the hearts of all "in order to salvation, if not resisted" (Barclay, Props. V–VI). Those who resist it bring condemnation on themselves (Props. V–VI, IX).
Conversion is entirely God's work: faith comes from hearing the Word , no one can say Jesus is Lord except by the Holy Spirit , and faith is the gift of God . The unconverted will contributes nothing. Yet the Spirit works through Word and sacrament in a way that can be resisted : those who are saved are saved by grace alone, and those who are lost are lost by their own fault (Formula of Concord, on free will and on election). Lutherans do not resolve this into a system. See .
Objection
Calvinists and Arminians both say this is inconsistent: if grace alone converts, why are not all who hear converted? And if some resist, the others must have cooperated, as when Paul says to work out your salvation .
Response
Scripture teaches both, and so must the church. Filling the gap with logic leads either to double predestination or to synergism (a human contribution to conversion). The believer cooperates after conversion, by the Spirit's power, not before it.
God always acts first, and the person, moved by his grace, freely accepts or refuses it, for God never forces love. Paul joins the two sides: work out your salvation, for it is God who works in you . Believers are God's fellow workers and must not receive his grace in vain . Christ stands at the door and knocks . See .
Objection
Protestants object that salvation does not depend on human will or exertion but on God who has mercy , so cooperation makes the human part decisive.
Response
Romans 9 teaches that mercy is God's free gift, never earned; it does not teach that God compels the will. And cooperation is itself a gift of grace, so there is nothing to boast of.
Catholic: Catholic teaching holds that the preparation for grace is already a work of grace (Catechism 2001), and that a person moved by grace freely consents and can also refuse (Council of Trent, Sixth Session, canon 4), for it is God who works in us . The Council of Orange (529) already taught both that grace must come first and that the baptized can cooperate with it.
Orthodox: The Orthodox teach this priority of grace as synergy, cooperation with the God who works in us , lived in the Church and its Mysteries (Ware).
The gospel is itself God's grace: the Spirit works through the Word, so no separate grace is needed before a person can believe. Paul calls the gospel the power of God for salvation to everyone who believes and says faith comes by hearing the word of Christ . God brought us forth by the word of truth , and the word of God is living and active . So whoever is willing may take the water of life freely . And this grace can be refused: you always resist the Holy Spirit .
Objection
Reformed and Wesleyan critics object that no one can come to Christ unless the Father draws him , so fallen people need more than information to turn to God.
Response
The next verse says how the Father draws: they will all be taught by God, and everyone who hears and learns from the Father comes . The Word is not mere information; it is the Spirit's own instrument.