Soteriology Compared Support
12 of 14 · Soteriology · Extent of the atonement

For Whom Did Christ Die?

Did Christ die to save the elect only, or for every person?

How this debate fits Calvinism, Arminianism and other systems →

Definite (limited) atonement

Argument

Christ died to save those the Father chose, and his death actually secures their salvation rather than only making it possible; Father, Son and Spirit share one purpose. Jesus says the good shepherd lays down his life for the sheep , and Paul says Christ loved the church and gave himself up for her . He came to save his people from their sins ; he obtained the church with his own blood and ransomed people from every tribe and nation . His death is sufficient for the whole world but was intended to save the elect (Canons of Dort II.3, II.8). See .

Objection

Those who hold universal atonement point out that Scripture calls Christ the propitiation for the sins of the whole world , says God desires all people to be saved , and says false teachers deny the Master who bought them .

Response

In 1 John 2:2, "world" means people of every nation, not only Jews . In 1 Timothy 2:4, "all people" means all kinds of people, or refers to God's revealed desire rather than his saving purpose. And if Christ paid for the sins of everyone, God would punish the same sins twice when the lost are judged (John Owen). The gospel is still offered sincerely to all.

Reformed: Reformed confessions teach definite (particular) redemption: Christ lays down his life for the sheep and effectually applies redemption to all for whom he purchased it (Canons of Dort II.8; Westminster Confession 8.5, 8.8). A minority of Reformed theologians (John Davenant at Dort, Edmund Calamy at Westminster) held hypothetical universalism, and some scholars argue the Westminster wording does not exclude it.

Universal atonement, received by faith

Argument

Christ died for every person, so salvation is open to all; it is received through faith, and those who are lost are lost by refusing it, not because no provision was made for them. John says Christ is the propitiation not for our sins only but for the sins of the whole world . God so loved the world that whoever believes will not perish ; he desires all people to be saved , and Christ gave himself as a ransom for all . By God's grace he tasted death for everyone and died for all , even for false teachers who deny him .

Objection

Reformed critics object that if Christ paid for everyone's sins and some are still lost, his death did not actually save anyone by itself; it only made salvation possible. They add that Scripture says he died for his sheep and his church .

Response

A gift fully paid can still be refused: the benefit of Christ's death is real for all and is applied by the means each tradition teaches, such as faith through Word and Sacrament, baptism and the Church, obeying the gospel, or not resisting the inward Light. And dying for the sheep does not mean dying only for them. Most of the church, East and West, has read 1 John 2:2 this way.

Methodist / Wesleyan: Echoing , Article XX of the Methodist Articles of Religion calls Christ's offering "that perfect redemption, propitiation, and satisfaction for all the sins of the whole world, both original and actual".

Lutheran: Christ made full satisfaction for the sins of the whole world, because he is the propitiation not for ours only but also for the sins of the whole world ; the forgiveness he won for all is given through Word and Sacrament and received by faith, since God desires all people to be saved (Formula of Concord XI). Some Lutheran bodies (LCMS, WELS, ELS) also speak of 'objective justification'; a minority of Lutherans dispute that term.

Orthodox: The Orthodox confess that Christ died "for the life of the world" and tasted death for everyone , trampling down death for all, so that in Christ all will be made alive . Each person receives union with him through faith, baptism and life in the Church; the question is not framed as payment for a set number of sins.

Quaker: Barclay taught that Christ died for every person, since by God's grace he tasted death for everyone (Props. V–VI). Its benefit is received by not resisting the inward Light of Christ that enlightens everyone , which is possible even for those who never heard the outward gospel.

Oneness Pentecostal: Christ died for every person, since he is the propitiation for the sins of the whole world . His death is applied when a person obeys the gospel by repenting, being baptized in Jesus' name for the remission of sins and receiving the Holy Ghost .

Hypothetical universalism (Amyraldism)

Moïse Amyraut and the school of Saumur; some Reformed Anglicans (John Davenant) and evangelicals

Argument

Christ died for all on the condition of faith, but God gives faith only to the elect, so only they are saved. Paul calls God the Savior of all people, especially of those who believe . Because Christ died for all who believe , the gospel can be offered to everyone in good faith. But no one believes on their own, so God also chose to give faith to the elect. See .

Objection

Strict Calvinists say it splits God's purpose in two: a decree that Christ die for all which God knows will save no one by itself. Arminians say a universal provision is empty if God gives faith only to some.

Response

Scripture itself holds both truths together: God's love for the world and his choice of a people . The view keeps the universal texts and the particular ones without forcing either.

Universal reconciliation

Christian universalists, historic (Origen, by some readings; Gregory of Nyssa) and modern (David Bentley Hart)

Argument

Christ's death will finally save every person. Paul says that through Christ God reconciles all things to himself , and that as in Adam all die, so in Christ all will be made alive . One act of righteousness leads to justification and life for all , and God has bound all over to disobedience so that he may have mercy on all . See .

Objection

Opponents object that Jesus speaks of eternal punishment alongside eternal life , and that the church condemned the teaching that all will be restored (Second Council of Constantinople, 553, as commonly understood).

Response

Universalists read the Greek word for eternal as belonging to the age to come rather than endless, and judgment as corrective. All fifteen traditions on this site reject this view as official teaching.