Definite (limited) atonement
Argument
Christ died to save those the Father chose, and his death actually secures their salvation rather than only making it possible; Father, Son and Spirit share one purpose. Jesus says the good shepherd lays down his life for the sheep , and Paul says Christ loved the church and gave himself up for her . He came to save his people from their sins ; he obtained the church with his own blood and ransomed people from every tribe and nation . His death is sufficient for the whole world but was intended to save the elect (Canons of Dort II.3, II.8). See .
Objection
Those who hold universal atonement point out that Scripture calls Christ the propitiation for the sins of the whole world , says God desires all people to be saved , and says false teachers deny the Master who bought them .
Response
In 1 John 2:2, "world" means people of every nation, not only Jews . In 1 Timothy 2:4, "all people" means all kinds of people, or refers to God's revealed desire rather than his saving purpose. And if Christ paid for the sins of everyone, God would punish the same sins twice when the lost are judged (John Owen). The gospel is still offered sincerely to all.
Reformed: Reformed confessions teach definite (particular) redemption: Christ lays down his life for the sheep and effectually applies redemption to all for whom he purchased it (Canons of Dort II.8; Westminster Confession 8.5, 8.8). A minority of Reformed theologians (John Davenant at Dort, Edmund Calamy at Westminster) held hypothetical universalism, and some scholars argue the Westminster wording does not exclude it.