Soteriology Compared Support
10 of 14 · Soteriology · Perseverance

Can Salvation Be Lost?

Is the believer secure forever, or can they fall away?

Perseverance of the saints

Argument

The Reformed teach that everyone God truly saves will persevere to the end, because God keeps them. Christ's sheep will never perish and no one will snatch them out of his hand ; he loses none the Father gives him . God completes the good work he began : all he justifies he glorifies , and nothing separates them from his love . They are guarded by God's power , kept from stumbling , and Christ always intercedes for them . Those who left were not of us . See .

Objection

Arminian critics point to the warning passages and to real people who made shipwreck of their faith , which suggest true believers can fall away.

Response

The Reformed answer that the warnings are the means God uses to keep the elect persevering (Schreiner and Caneday). Those who fall away completely were never truly regenerate, which is why Jesus will say I never knew you .

Once saved, always saved

Free Grace theology (Zane Hodges, Charles Ryrie), some independent Baptists

Argument

Free Grace teachers hold that once a person believes, salvation can never be lost. Whoever believes has eternal life now and will not come into judgment . Believers are sealed with the Spirit for the day of redemption , God's gifts and calling are irrevocable , and there is no condemnation for those in Christ . See and .

Objection

Reformed and Arminian critics say this implies someone can reject Christ and still be saved, against if we deny him, he also will deny us and the warnings of Hebrews .

Response

Free Grace teachers answer that the next line says if we are faithless, he remains faithful , so denial costs rewards, not salvation: the person suffers loss but is saved as through fire . Critics of this view () reply that saving faith includes submission to Christ.

Lost only if faith dies

LutheranReformed Arminians (Free Will Baptists), who hold that apostasy cannot be undone

Argument

Lutherans teach that salvation is held by faith, so if faith dies, union with Christ ends. Hebrews warns against an unbelieving heart that falls away, for we share in Christ if we hold firm to the end ; believers will be presented holy if they continue in the faith ; and branches that do not abide are thrown away . Sins of weakness do not undo salvation, for we have an advocate with the Father . But unbelief, or deliberate sin against conscience, drives out faith and the Holy Spirit. See .

Objection

Calvinists object that this makes salvation depend on the believer's own strength and undermines assurance, though Jesus promises that no one will snatch his sheep out of his hand .

Response

Lutherans answer that believers are guarded by God's power through faith , not by their own strength. Assurance rests on Christ's promises received now in Word and sacrament, not on predicting the future. Those who fall can be restored through repentance and absolution, as David was.

Can be lost and restored

Argument

Believers can truly fall away, and the fallen can truly be restored. The warnings are meant seriously: those once enlightened can fall away , no sacrifice remains for wilful sin , the last state can become worse than the first , and some have fallen away from grace . Those who do not continue will be cut off , and a righteous person who turns away will die . Yet the lost son was dead and is alive again , whoever brings back a wanderer saves a soul , and the fallen are called to repent and do the works they did at first .

Objection

Reformed and most Baptist critics object that Hebrews 6:6 calls it impossible to restore such people to repentance, which contradicts restoration. They add that the view breeds anxiety, against the promises that no one will snatch Christ's sheep and nothing can separate believers from God's love .

Response

Holders answer that Hebrews 6 describes final, hardened apostasy, not every fall, so ordinary backsliders are still urged to return . Scripture joins God's promises to the call to endure: the one who endures to the end will be saved .

Catholic: Catholics teach that sanctifying grace is lost through , since John distinguishes sin that leads to death from sin that does not , and that it is restored through the sacrament of Penance and Reconciliation (Confession).

Orthodox: The Orthodox restore the fallen through Confession, the Mystery of Repentance, receiving them as the father received the son who was dead and is alive again .

Resurrection secure, exaltation conditional

Argument

Latter-day Saints distinguish general salvation from exaltation. Christ's atonement guarantees resurrection to all , but exaltation requires enduring to the end . See .

Objection

Other Christians object that the Bible does not split salvation into two tiers.

Response

Latter-day Saints answer that Paul already distinguishes glories like those of the sun, moon and stars .