Anglican
The Church of England after its break with Rome (1534) and the worldwide Anglican Communion.
Key figures: Thomas Cranmer, Richard Hooker, John Stott, C.S. Lewis, N.T. Wright
A broad tradition that holds evangelical (often Reformed), Anglo-Catholic and broad (liberal) traditions together around the Book of Common Prayer and the Thirty-Nine Articles. The Articles teach justification by faith and predestination, but many Anglicans hold Arminian views. Practice ranges from a Reformed view of the sacraments to a Catholic one.
Its position in each of the 14 debates
| Debate | Position and main argument |
|---|---|
| 1. The Nature of God | Trinity Scripture insists there is one God , yet it calls the Father, the Son and the Spirit God , and it names all three together in one baptismal name and one blessing . Only one being in three persons () holds all of these texts together. |
| 2. Authority: Scripture and Tradition | Scripture first (Quadrilateral) Scripture is the primary authority, but it is not read alone: the church's tradition and sound reason help interpret it (), and so does the Spirit's witness in the believer . This is the careful reading Paul asks for when he says to test everything and hold fast what is good . Anglicans speak of three sources, Scripture, tradition and reason, with Scripture primary as the God-breathed word . |
| 3. Original Sin and Human Nature | Inherited guilt, total depravity Every person inherits Adam's guilt and a nature corrupted throughout. In Adam all die , and by one man's disobedience the many were made sinners , so David confesses he was brought forth in iniquity . Fallen people are therefore dead in trespasses and sins and by nature children of wrath . The heart is deceitful above all things , and no one seeks God . See and . Article IX teaches that every person is born "very far gone from original righteousness" and deserving God's wrath, because sin entered the world through one man and we are sinful from conception ; evangelicals read this as total depravity, Anglo-Catholics as a wounded nature. |
| 4. Free Will and Predestination | Article XVII teaches that God chose in Christ, before the world began, those he would bring to everlasting life, echoing and following the order of : called, justified, conformed to Christ's image, glorified. Anglicans disagree on whether that election is unconditional (the Reformed reading) or rests on foreseen faith (the Arminian reading), and the Article warns against curious speculation either way. |
| 5. The Atonement | The Prayer Book calls Christ's death "a full, perfect, and sufficient sacrifice, oblation, and satisfaction, for the sins of the whole world" (BCP 1662, Prayer of Consecration; see also Article II). Evangelical Anglicans commonly read this as penal substitution, since he bore our sins in his body on the tree , while Anglo-Catholics are closer to a satisfaction view. |
| 6. The Order of Salvation | The Prayer Book links the new birth to baptism: the rite for infants opens with Christ's words that no one enters the kingdom unless born of water and the Spirit and then declares the child "regenerate." Anglo-Catholics take this as baptismal regeneration; evangelicals read it covenantally, as a sign and pledge of a new birth received by faith. |
| 7. Justification | Forensic, faith alone God declares sinners righteous by faith alone, apart from works. Paul says one is justified by faith apart from works of the law and that God justifies the ungodly , as when Abraham believed God and it was counted to him as righteousness . This righteousness comes from God and depends on faith , not on works of the law , because Christ's righteousness is credited to believers . So they have peace with God . See , and . |
| 8. Sanctification | Progressive, incomplete Believers grow in holiness throughout life but are never sinless before glory. Scripture warns that if we say we have no sin, we deceive ourselves . Paul describes wanting the good yet doing evil , and the flesh and the Spirit war against each other . So believers are being transformed from one degree of glory to another , pressing on because they are not yet perfect . See . Article XV teaches that all Christians, though baptized and born again in Christ, still offend in many things, and it quotes John: if we say we have no sin, we deceive ourselves . |
| 9. Baptism and the Lord's Supper | Anglicans baptize infants and keep Baptism and the Lord's Supper as the two "Sacraments of the Gospel" (Article XXV), bringing children to Christ as he told his disciples to . The Prayer Book declares the baptized child "regenerate" and Article XXVII calls baptism a "sign of Regeneration or new Birth"; Anglo-Catholics read this as baptismal regeneration, evangelicals covenantally. Article XXVIII calls the Supper a partaking of the body and blood of Christ , received "only after an heavenly and spiritual manner," and rejects transubstantiation; views range from a Reformed spiritual presence to an Anglo-Catholic real presence. |
| 10. Can Salvation Be Lost? | Anglicanism has not settled this: Article XVI says believers "may depart from grace given, and fall into sin," and by God's grace "arise again," and the Prayer Book's Comfortable Words assure the sinner of an Advocate with the Father . Arminian Anglicans read this as salvation that can be lost and restored; Reformed Anglicans hold perseverance, trusting that God will complete the good work he began . |
| 11. The Unevangelized | Salvation comes only through Christ: Article XVIII condemns the claim that anyone is saved by the law or sect they profess, because Scripture sets out "only the Name of Jesus Christ, whereby men must be saved" . Evangelicals hold that explicit faith is required; many broad-church and Anglo-Catholic Anglicans are inclusivists, holding that God may save through Christ some who never knew his name, since in every nation whoever fears him is acceptable to him . |
| 12. For Whom Did Christ Die? | Article XXXI calls Christ's offering "perfect redemption, propitiation, and satisfaction, for all the sins of the whole world," echoing . Arminian Anglicans read this as universal atonement. Reformed Anglicans read it either as sufficient for all but effective for the elect or, like John Davenant (British delegation at Dort), as hypothetical universalism; the Church of England never adopted the Canons of Dort. |
| 13. Can Grace Be Resisted? | Article X teaches that no one can turn to God "by our own natural strength and good works" unless God's grace goes before us ("preventing us") and works with us, for it is God who works in us both to will and to do . Reformed Anglicans hold that this calling is effectual; Arminian Anglicans hold that it can be resisted, as when people resist the Holy Spirit ; Anglo-Catholics speak of grace that goes before the will and then works with it. |
| 14. The Afterlife and Final Destiny | Anglicans confess in the Creeds the return of Christ, the resurrection, judgment and the life everlasting, and the traditional teaching of eternal punishment, drawn from Christ's words and echoed in the Athanasian Creed's "everlasting fire," is the standard view. Some, such as John Stott, tentatively favoured annihilationism, pointing to God's power to destroy body and soul in hell , and the Church of England Doctrine Commission's The Mystery of Salvation (1995) leaned the same way. |
Official documents and key works
Thirty-Nine Articles of Religion (Church of England, 1563/1571); The Cross of Christ (John Stott, 1986)