Soteriology Compared Support
4 of 14 · Soteriology · Election

Free Will and Predestination

Does God choose who is saved, or do people choose God?

How this debate fits Calvinism, Arminianism and other systems →

Unconditional election

Argument

God chooses whom he will save, before and apart from anything they do. He chose his people before the foundation of the world according to the purpose of his will , before they had done anything good or bad , so salvation depends not on human will but on God who has mercy . His choice is effective: no one can come unless the Father draws him, and those drawn are raised up ; all the Father gives will come ; as many as were appointed to eternal life believed . See .

Objection

Arminian critics say it makes God arbitrary, contradicts God's desire that all be saved and Jesus' lament over those who would not come , and seems to make evangelism pointless.

Response

First, all deserve judgment, so election is mercy, not injustice ; Jesus chose his disciples, not they him . Second, 1 Tim 2:4 speaks of all kinds of people or of God's revealed desire. Third, God ordains the means as well as the end, so preaching is how the elect are called .

Conditional election (foreseen faith)

Argument

God's election is open to all and is conditioned on faith, not fixed apart from the human response. Believers are elect according to the foreknowledge of God . God loved the world so that whoever believes may have life ; he does not wish that any should perish and takes no pleasure in the death of the wicked . The offer can be refused: Jesus longed to gather Jerusalem, but they were not willing , and people can resist the Holy Spirit . Whoever wishes may take the water of life . See .

Objection

Reformed critics say foreknew in Rom 8:29 means God set his love on persons beforehand, not that he foresaw their choices. If election rests on faith, the decisive factor is human, which gives grounds to boast.

Response

Peter says believers are elect according to the foreknowledge of God , so election follows God's foreknowledge of those in Christ . Faith only receives a gift and is not a work , so there is nothing to boast in. Romans 9 concerns the historical roles of Israel and the nations (Jacob and Esau), not individual salvation.

Churches of Christ: Most teach corporate election: God chose a people in Christ, as Paul says he chose us in him before the foundation of the world . Individuals enter that people by obeying the gospel and being baptized into Christ .

Quaker: Barclay's frame is universal saving grace offered to everyone in a "day of visitation", because God desires all people to be saved . A person can still resist it, as Stephen told those who always resist the Holy Spirit (Apology, Props. V–VI).

Election to salvation only (no double predestination)

Argument

God elects to salvation by grace alone, but he does not choose anyone for damnation. Scripture teaches both that God elects by grace and that he wants all to be saved , and Lutherans affirm both. Destruction is the sinner's own doing, while help is from God . See .

Objection

Reformed critics say this is logically incoherent: if God alone chooses who is saved, then passing over the rest is also God's decision, and Reformed confessions say so openly: God passes by the rest and ordains them to dishonour and wrath for their sin (Westminster Confession 3.7).

Response

Lutherans accept the tension as a mystery of God's hidden will. The secret things belong to God , and his ways are unsearchable . Theology stops where Scripture stops (Formula of Concord XI).

Grace first, free cooperation (synergy)

Argument

God's grace always comes first, and people freely cooperate with it. Paul holds both together: work out your own salvation, for it is God who works in you . Christ stands at the door and knocks , and believers work together with him . See .

Objection

Reformed critics say this makes a human act the decisive difference between the saved and the lost . Other Protestants hear it as salvation by works.

Response

The cooperation is itself enabled by grace: no one turns to God without grace that comes first, so the human response never stands apart from God's work and is not salvation by works.

Catholic: Catholics cite Trent, which condemns the idea that anyone turns to God without prior grace (Session VI, canons 1–3), since it is God who works in us . Catholic theologians debate how grace and freedom fit together: Thomists stress the efficacy of grace, Molinists human freedom (); the Church permits both (De Auxiliis, 1607).

Orthodox: Orthodoxy speaks of synergy without the Western predestination debates: grace always comes first, and human freedom accepts it without earning anything, as believers work together with God .

Agency from a premortal life

Argument

Every person had agency before birth, and salvation depends on how it is used in this life. All lived as spirit children of God: before God formed Jeremiah he knew him , and the sons of God shouted for joy at creation . Agency was given in a premortal council. Foreordination is to roles and opportunities; salvation depends on the choices made in this life .

Objection

Other Christians object that Jer 1:5 speaks of God's foreknowledge of Jeremiah, not a pre-existing soul, and that the Bible never teaches a premortal life for all people.

Response

Knowing someone before forming them implies that person existed to be known, and Job 38 places the sons of God at creation.