Soteriology Compared Support
At a glance

15 traditions × 14 debates

Each cell shows the position a tradition holds. Italic cells describe a split or a nuance within that tradition. Click or tap a cell to read what the position means. A † marks a note on how that tradition holds the position. * Outside historic Nicene Christianity; these groups identify themselves as Christian.

DebateCatholicOrthodoxLutheranReformedAnglicanMethodist / WesleyanBaptistPentecostalMennoniteChurches of ChristAdventistQuakerOneness Pentecostal *Latter-day Saints *Jehovah's Witnesses *
Foundations
1The Nature of GodTrinityTrinityTrinityTrinityTrinityTrinityTrinityTrinityTrinityTrinityTrinityHistoric and Evangelical Friends confess one God, Father, Son and Holy Spirit, and confess Christ as the eternal Word who was God, though early Friends avoided the word "Trinity" because it is not a scriptural term; many modern liberal Meetings hold no fixed creed.OnenessThree beingsFather alone is God
2Authority: Scripture and TraditionScripture + Tradition + MagisteriumHoly TraditionScripture aloneScripture aloneScripture first (Quadrilateral)Scripture first (Quadrilateral)Scripture aloneScripture aloneScripture aloneScripture aloneScripture aloneInner LightScripture aloneBible + living prophetsBible via Governing Body
3Original Sin and Human NatureOriginal sin, washed in baptismAncestral sinInherited guilt, total depravityInherited guilt, total depravityInherited guilt, total depravityFallen, prevenient graceBaptists teach that everyone inherits from Adam a fallen nature inclined to sin, as David confesses he was sinful from birth, and the Baptist Faith and Message (art. III) says people become transgressors as soon as they are capable of moral action, so many Baptists deny that infants bear guilt (the age of accountability). Others, following the 1689 Confession (ch. 6), hold that Adam's guilt is passed to all his descendants, because sin and death came to all through one man.Fallen, prevenient gracePersonal guilt onlyPersonal guilt onlyFallen, prevenient graceFriends teach that all people inherit a fallen nature, dead in trespasses and sins, and carry a seed of sin. This seed is not counted against infants until they sin themselves, because the son shall not bear the iniquity of the father, and Christ's Light is offered to everyone (Barclay, Props. IV–V).Fallen, prevenient gracePersonal guilt onlyJehovah's Witnesses teach that all humans inherited sin and imperfection from Adam, and these bring death to all, because sin entered the world through one man and death through sin.
Soteriology
4Free Will and PredestinationSynergySynergySingle predestinationUnconditional electionArticle XVII teaches that God chose in Christ, before the world began, those he would bring to everlasting life, echoing and following the order of: called, justified, conformed to Christ's image, glorified. Anglicans disagree on whether that election is unconditional (the Reformed reading) or rests on foreseen faith (the Arminian reading), and the Article warns against curious speculation either way.Conditional electionBaptists are divided. Reformed Baptists hold unconditional election, because God chose us in Christ before the foundation of the world. Most other Baptists hold conditional election or a middle view, reading believers as elect according to the foreknowledge of God. The Baptist Faith and Message (art. V) affirms election as consistent with the free agency of man.Conditional electionConditional electionConditional electionConditional electionConditional electionConditional electionPremortal agencyGod did not predestine individuals: he foreordained a class (the anointed), uses his foreknowledge selectively, and leaves each person to choose, as Joshua urged Israel to choose whom they would serve.
5The AtonementSatisfactionChristus VictorPenal substitutionPenal substitutionThe Prayer Book calls Christ's death "a full, perfect, and sufficient sacrifice, oblation, and satisfaction, for the sins of the whole world" (BCP 1662, Prayer of Consecration; see also Article II). Evangelical Anglicans commonly read this as penal substitution, since he bore our sins in his body on the tree, while Anglo-Catholics are closer to a satisfaction view.Penal substitutionPenal substitutionPenal substitutionMennonites teach that Christ's death and resurrection free people from sin and the powers of evil and reconcile them to God, and the 1995 Confession (art. 8) holds several images together: sacrifice, ransom (he came to give his life as a ransom for many) and victory over the powers, which Christ disarmed and triumphed over on the cross. Some modern Mennonite theologians, such as J. Denny Weaver, teach a nonviolent atonement.Penal substitutionPenal substitutionChrist's death is the one sacrifice for sin, the propitiation for the sins of the whole world, but Friends hold no fixed theory of how it works and stress Christ's work within the believer. Evangelical Friends affirm Christ's death as a propitiatory sacrifice.Penal substitutionGethsemane + crossCorresponding ransom
6The Order of SalvationLifelong processLifelong processNew birth in baptismRegeneration → faithThe Prayer Book links the new birth to baptism: the rite for infants opens with Christ's words that no one enters the kingdom unless born of water and the Spirit and then declares the child "regenerate." Anglo-Catholics take this as baptismal regeneration; evangelicals read it covenantally, as a sign and pledge of a new birth received by faith.Faith → regenerationBaptists are divided. Reformed Baptists teach that regeneration comes first and produces faith (1689 Confession ch. 10), because everyone who believes has been born of God. Most other Baptists teach that faith comes first and new life follows, since by believing we have life in his name. Both sides treat conversion as a definite event, followed by lifelong sanctification.Faith → regenerationFaith → regenerationNew birth in baptismFaith → regenerationFor Friends, salvation is an inward process with no fixed order: the Light that enlightens everyone works in the heart and leads to the new birth without which no one can see the kingdom of God.New birth in baptismLatter-day Saints teach that a person is born again by faith in Christ, repentance and baptism of water and of the Spirit, as Jesus tells Nicodemus. The order is faith, repentance, baptism by immersion by priesthood authority, then the gift of the Holy Ghost by the laying on of hands (Article of Faith 4), as Peter teaches at Pentecost; rebirth then continues as a lifelong process of enduring to the end.Salvation is a process, not a single event: a person studies the Bible, dedicates himself to Jehovah, then is baptized as the public symbol of that dedication, as Jesus commanded his followers to make disciples and baptize them. Being born again, which Jesus links to seeing the Kingdom of God, applies only to the 144,000 anointed who will rule in heaven, not to the majority who have an earthly hope.
7JustificationInfused righteousnessTheosisForensic, faith aloneForensic, faith aloneForensic, faith aloneForensic, faith aloneForensic, faith aloneForensic, faith aloneObedient faithObedient faithForensic, faith aloneThe sinner is made righteous, not only declared righteous. Remission of sins comes through Christ's outward sacrifice, and justification is being made righteous by Christ revealed within, since God saves us by the washing of regeneration and renewing of the Holy Spirit (Barclay, Prop. VII).Oneness Pentecostals teach that the sinner is forgiven and made a new creature through the new birth, by grace through obedient faith: repentance, baptism in Jesus' name for the remission of sins, and receiving the Holy Ghost with tongues, because no one enters the kingdom without being born of water and of the Spirit.Grace + covenantsGod counts a person righteous on the basis of faith in the ransom, and that faith must be shown by faithful obedience, because faith without works is dead; full justification comes only after the final test at the end of the Thousand Years.
8SanctificationGrowth in grace / theosisGrowth in grace / theosisProgressive, incompleteProgressive, incompleteProgressive, incompleteEntire sanctificationProgressive, incompletePentecostals agree that believers must pursue the holiness without which no one will see the Lord (AG Fundamental Truth 9), but they are divided on how far it goes in this life. Holiness bodies such as the Church of God (Cleveland) and the Pentecostal Holiness Church teach entire sanctification as a definite work after conversion, in line with Paul's prayer that God would sanctify you completely; the Assemblies of God teach progressive sanctification over a lifetime.Discipleship in communityProgressive, incompleteProgressive, incompletePerfection is possible in this life, because whoever is born of God does not keep on sinning and Christ commands be perfect. This is freedom from sinning by the power of Christ within, with room to grow and the possibility of falling (Barclay, Prop. VIII).Believers grow in holiness throughout their lives after the new birth, inwardly and in outward conduct, because without holiness no one will see the Lord. Grace teaches believers to deny ungodliness and live soberly, and the UPCI applies this through practical holiness standards such as modest dress and women's uncut hair (1 Cor 11).Eternal progressionBelievers prove their faithfulness through clean conduct, the preaching work and separation from the world, as Paul urges them not to be conformed to this world.
9Baptism and the Lord's SupperSacramental (real change)Sacramental (real change)Sacramental unionCovenant signs, spiritual presenceAnglicans baptize infants and keep Baptism and the Lord's Supper as the two "Sacraments of the Gospel" (Article XXV), bringing children to Christ as he told his disciples to. The Prayer Book declares the baptized child "regenerate" and Article XXVII calls baptism a "sign of Regeneration or new Birth"; Anglo-Catholics read this as baptismal regeneration, evangelicals covenantally. Article XXVIII calls the Supper a partaking of the body and blood of Christ, received "only after an heavenly and spiritual manner," and rejects transubstantiation; views range from a Reformed spiritual presence to an Anglo-Catholic real presence.Covenant signs, spiritual presenceOrdinances (believers, memorial)Ordinances (believers, memorial)Ordinances (believers, memorial)Baptism requiredOrdinances (believers, memorial)Inward onlyBaptism requiredPriesthood ordinancesJehovah's Witnesses baptize by full immersion those who have personally dedicated themselves to Jehovah, not infants, as a public symbol of that dedication and as Jesus commanded his disciples. The Memorial of Christ's death is held once a year on Nisan 14; all are invited to attend, but only the anointed eat the unleavened bread and drink the wine, because only they have the witness of God's spirit that they are God's children.
10Can Salvation Be Lost?Lost and restoredLost and restoredLost if faith diesElect will persevereAnglicanism has not settled this: Article XVI says believers "may depart from grace given, and fall into sin," and by God's grace "arise again," and the Prayer Book's Comfortable Words assure the sinner of an Advocate with the Father. Arminian Anglicans read this as salvation that can be lost and restored; Reformed Anglicans hold perseverance, trusting that God will complete the good work he began.Lost and restoredMost Baptists answer that a true believer is secure forever and will persevere, because Jesus says no one will snatch his sheep out of his hand (Baptist Faith and Message V; 1689 Confession 17). Some independent Baptists hold the Free Grace form. Free Will Baptists hold that salvation can be lost through apostasy, pointing to warnings such as.Lost and restoredLost and restoredLost and restoredLost and restoredLost and restoredLost and restoredTwo-levelLost and restored
11The UnevangelizedInclusivismThe Orthodox give no fixed answer: there is salvation in no one but Christ, and those who never heard of him are left to the mercy of God, who desires all people to be saved. Their stance is hopeful reserve: we know where the Church is, but not where it is not.ExclusivismExclusivismSalvation comes only through Christ: Article XVIII condemns the claim that anyone is saved by the law or sect they profess, because Scripture sets out "only the Name of Jesus Christ, whereby men must be saved". Evangelicals hold that explicit faith is required; many broad-church and Anglo-Catholic Anglicans are inclusivists, holding that God may save through Christ some who never knew his name, since in every nation whoever fears him is acceptable to him.InclusivismExclusivismExclusivismMennonites have no single binding answer. Traditionally they held that salvation comes only through explicit faith in Christ, since there is no other name by which we must be saved; many modern Mennonites are inclusivist and trust that in every nation God accepts anyone who fears him and does what is right.ExclusivismInclusivismInclusivismExclusivismPost-mortem opportunityPost-mortem opportunity
12For Whom Did Christ Die?For all, received by faithFor all, received by faithFor all, received by faithFor the electArticle XXXI calls Christ's offering "perfect redemption, propitiation, and satisfaction, for all the sins of the whole world," echoing. Arminian Anglicans read this as universal atonement. Reformed Anglicans read it either as sufficient for all but effective for the elect or, like John Davenant (British delegation at Dort), as hypothetical universalism; the Church of England never adopted the Canons of Dort.For all, received by faithBaptists are divided, and the Baptist Faith and Message does not settle the question. Particular and Reformed Baptists hold definite atonement, as Jesus says he lays down his life for the sheep. Most other Baptists, including Free Will Baptists, General Baptists and probably most Southern Baptists, hold that Christ died for every person, since he is the propitiation for the sins of the whole world.For all, received by faithFor all, received by faithFor all, received by faithFor all, received by faithFor all, received by faithFor all, received by faithChrist died for every person. His Atonement is infinite (Alma 34:10), and it reaches everyone, because in Christ all will be made alive in the resurrection. Forgiveness and exaltation are received through faith, repentance, ordinances and covenants.Jesus gave his perfect human life as a corresponding ransom for all, matching the perfect life Adam lost. It is offered to all of Adam's offspring (Adam himself, who sinned wilfully, is not covered), but only those who exercise faith and obey benefit from it, since God gave his Son so that everyone who believes in him should not perish.
13Can Grace Be Resisted?Cooperating graceCooperating graceMonergistic, resistibleEffectual callingArticle X teaches that no one can turn to God "by our own natural strength and good works" unless God's grace goes before us ("preventing us") and works with us, for it is God who works in us both to will and to do. Reformed Anglicans hold that this calling is effectual; Arminian Anglicans hold that it can be resisted, as when people resist the Holy Spirit; Anglo-Catholics speak of grace that goes before the will and then works with it.Enabling, resistibleBaptists are divided, and the Baptist Faith and Message does not settle the question. Calvinist Baptists hold effectual calling (1689 Confession ch. 10), because all whom the Father gives to Christ will come to him. Free Will Baptists hold resistible enabling grace, and many Southern Baptists (signers of the unofficial 2012 "Traditional Statement", sometimes called Provisionists) hold that the Spirit draws people through the gospel itself, which people can refuse as Jerusalem was not willing.Enabling, resistibleYes, grace can be refused. Anabaptists teach that God, through his Word preached to all, restores the will's freedom to answer in faith and obedience, and that this call can be refused, just as Jesus wanted to gather Jerusalem but they were not willing (Balthasar Hubmaier, On the Freedom of the Will, 1527). Mennonites speak of yieldedness (Gelassenheit) and discipleship rather than Arminian categories.Gospel enablesEnabling, resistibleEnabling, resistibleEnabling, resistibleYes, grace can be refused, because God invites and never forces, and each person must choose this day whom they will serve. The Light of Christ is given to every person to know good from evil (Moroni 7:16), the true light that enlightens everyone, and agency is central to the plan (2 Nephi 2:27). Latter-day Saints do not use the term "prevenient grace".Yes, God's call can be refused: Jehovah draws people through his holy spirit and the Bible's message, as Jesus said no one comes to him unless the Father draws him, but each person chooses whether to respond, since anyone who wishes may take the water of life freely. Witnesses do not use the categories of this debate.
The End
14The Afterlife and Final DestinyPlus purgatoryHeaven / hell as God's presenceHeaven / eternal hellHeaven / eternal hellAnglicans confess in the Creeds the return of Christ, the resurrection, judgment and the life everlasting, and the traditional teaching of eternal punishment, drawn from Christ's words and echoed in the Athanasian Creed's "everlasting fire," is the standard view. Some, such as John Stott, tentatively favoured annihilationism, pointing to God's power to destroy body and soul in hell, and the Church of England Doctrine Commission's The Mystery of Salvation (1995) leaned the same way.Heaven / eternal hellHeaven / eternal hellHeaven / eternal hellHeaven / eternal hellHeaven / eternal hellAnnihilationismHistoric and Evangelical Friends affirm the resurrection and eternal judgment, as Jesus says those who have done good will rise to life and those who have done evil to condemnation. Liberal Meetings hold no fixed doctrine on this and stress the present experience of God.Heaven / eternal hellThree degrees of gloryAnnihilationism