Soteriology Compared Support
Protestant (Magisterial Reformation)

Lutheran

Began with Martin Luther's reform in Germany (1517); doctrine set out in the Book of Concord (1580).

Key figures: Martin Luther, Philip Melanchthon, Martin Chemnitz

Justification by faith alone () is the centre. God alone saves (), yet Lutherans reject double predestination: God wants all to be saved, and those who are lost perish by their own unbelief. Baptism and the Lord's Supper are real . Salvation can be lost by falling away into unbelief.

Its position in each of the 14 debates

DebatePosition and main argument
1. The Nature of GodTrinity

Scripture insists there is one God , yet it calls the Father, the Son and the Spirit God , and it names all three together in one baptismal name and one blessing . Only one being in three persons () holds all of these texts together.

2. Authority: Scripture and TraditionScripture alone

Scripture alone is the final authority, because only Scripture is breathed out by God and it equips the believer for every good work , written by men carried along by the Holy Spirit . Jesus treated it this way: he answered temptation with Scripture and judged human tradition by it . The Bereans did the same, testing even Paul's preaching against the Scriptures . See .

3. Original Sin and Human NatureInherited guilt, total depravity

Every person inherits Adam's guilt and a nature corrupted throughout. In Adam all die , and by one man's disobedience the many were made sinners , so David confesses he was brought forth in iniquity . Fallen people are therefore dead in trespasses and sins and by nature children of wrath . The heart is deceitful above all things , and no one seeks God . See and .

Lutherans ground inherited sin in natural descent rather than in a covenant of representation: since the fall all are born with sin, as David says he was sinful from conception .

4. Free Will and PredestinationSingle predestination

God elects to salvation by grace alone, but he does not choose anyone for damnation. Scripture teaches both that God elects by grace and that he wants all to be saved , and Lutherans affirm both. Destruction is the sinner's own doing, while help is from God . See .

5. The AtonementPenal substitution

Christ's death saves by bearing, in our place, the penalty our sins deserved. Isaiah's servant was pierced for our transgressions as the LORD laid our iniquity on him ; it was the LORD's will to crush him . So God made him to be sin for us : he became a curse for us and bore our sins in his body , the righteous for the unrighteous . This shows God is just when he forgives , because without the shedding of blood there is no forgiveness . See .

6. The Order of SalvationNew birth in baptism

New birth happens through baptism, as Jesus says no one can enter the kingdom unless born of water and the Spirit . The apostles tie baptism to forgiveness: repent and be baptized for the forgiveness of sins ; be baptized and wash away your sins . Peter says baptism now saves you . Paul says God saved us by the washing of regeneration and that all who were baptized into Christ have put on Christ . See .

On the thief on the cross , Lutherans say baptism is ordinarily necessary but not absolutely necessary: whoever believes and is baptized will be saved , yet the same verse names only unbelief as what condemns. So it is contempt for baptism, not its lack, that condemns. In adults the Word creates faith before baptism.

7. JustificationForensic, faith alone

God declares sinners righteous by faith alone, apart from works. Paul says one is justified by faith apart from works of the law and that God justifies the ungodly , as when Abraham believed God and it was counted to him as righteousness . This righteousness comes from God and depends on faith , not on works of the law , because Christ's righteousness is credited to believers . So they have peace with God . See , and .

8. SanctificationProgressive, incomplete

Believers grow in holiness throughout life but are never sinless before glory. Scripture warns that if we say we have no sin, we deceive ourselves . Paul describes wanting the good yet doing evil , and the flesh and the Spirit war against each other . So believers are being transformed from one degree of glory to another , pressing on because they are not yet perfect . See .

Lutherans call this : the believer is at the same time righteous in Christ and still a sinner, as Paul's struggle with sin shows.

9. Baptism and the Lord's SupperSacramental union

Lutherans teach that Christ's body and blood are truly present in, with and under the bread and wine, and that baptism truly forgives sins. They take this is my body and this is my blood of the covenant, poured out for the forgiveness of sins at face value, without a philosophical explanation of how (). Baptism likewise gives the forgiveness it promises and saves through the washing of new birth . Word and sacrament are , the ways God gives grace.

10. Can Salvation Be Lost?Lost if faith dies

Lutherans teach that salvation is held by faith, so if faith dies, union with Christ ends. Hebrews warns against an unbelieving heart that falls away, for we share in Christ if we hold firm to the end ; believers will be presented holy if they continue in the faith ; and branches that do not abide are thrown away . Sins of weakness do not undo salvation, for we have an advocate with the Father . But unbelief, or deliberate sin against conscience, drives out faith and the Holy Spirit. See .

11. The UnevangelizedExclusivism

Salvation requires conscious faith in Jesus Christ, because there is salvation in no one else . Jesus said no one comes to the Father except through him , and there is only one mediator between God and people . Faith comes by hearing the gospel: how will they believe in him of whom they have never heard ? So people must be told about Christ in order to believe in him. See .

12. For Whom Did Christ Die?For all, received by faith

Christ died for every person, so salvation is open to all; it is received through faith, and those who are lost are lost by refusing it, not because no provision was made for them. John says Christ is the propitiation not for our sins only but for the sins of the whole world . God so loved the world that whoever believes will not perish ; he desires all people to be saved , and Christ gave himself as a ransom for all . By God's grace he tasted death for everyone and died for all , even for false teachers who deny him .

Christ made full satisfaction for the sins of the whole world, because he is the propitiation not for ours only but also for the sins of the whole world ; the forgiveness he won for all is given through Word and Sacrament and received by faith, since God desires all people to be saved (Formula of Concord XI). Some Lutheran bodies (LCMS, WELS, ELS) also speak of 'objective justification'; a minority of Lutherans dispute that term.

13. Can Grace Be Resisted?Monergistic, resistible

Conversion is entirely God's work: faith comes from hearing the Word , no one can say Jesus is Lord except by the Holy Spirit , and faith is the gift of God . The unconverted will contributes nothing. Yet the Spirit works through Word and sacrament in a way that can be resisted : those who are saved are saved by grace alone, and those who are lost are lost by their own fault (Formula of Concord, on free will and on election). Lutherans do not resolve this into a system. See .

14. The Afterlife and Final DestinyHeaven / eternal hell

The righteous enter eternal life, and the wicked suffer conscious punishment that never ends. Jesus sets the two side by side: they will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life . He sends the wicked into the eternal fire prepared for the devil , where their worm does not die and the fire is not quenched . Revelation says they will be tormented day and night forever and the smoke of their torment goes up forever . Paul calls it eternal destruction away from the presence of the Lord .

Official documents and key works

The Book of Concord (Augsburg Confession; Small Catechism; Formula of Concord) (Lutheran Church, 1530–1580)