Methodist / Wesleyan
The 18th-century revival led by John and Charles Wesley in England; includes Methodists, Nazarenes and the Holiness movement.
Key figures: John Wesley, Charles Wesley, Francis Asbury, Phoebe Palmer, Jacobus Arminius (theological ancestor)
God's reaches every person and frees the will to respond. Christ died for all, grace can be resisted, and salvation can be lost and restored. Wesleyans stress holiness of heart and life and teach , or Christian perfection, as perfect love.
Its position in each of the 14 debates
| Debate | Position and main argument |
|---|---|
| 1. The Nature of God | Trinity Scripture insists there is one God , yet it calls the Father, the Son and the Spirit God , and it names all three together in one baptismal name and one blessing . Only one being in three persons () holds all of these texts together. |
| 2. Authority: Scripture and Tradition | Scripture first (Quadrilateral) Scripture is the primary authority, but it is not read alone: the church's tradition and sound reason help interpret it (), and so does the Spirit's witness in the believer . This is the careful reading Paul asks for when he says to test everything and hold fast what is good . Wesley added experience, the Spirit bearing witness with our spirit , to Scripture, tradition and reason, yet called himself a man of one book. |
| 3. Original Sin and Human Nature | Fallen, prevenient grace People are truly fallen and cannot turn to God on their own, but God's grace restores the ability to respond. This reaches everyone: the grace of God has appeared bringing salvation to all people , Christ draws all people to himself , and he enlightens everyone . So God commands all people everywhere to repent . Nazarenes and many Methodists hold that Christ's atonement covers children before they can choose, since the kingdom belongs to little children ; Wesley himself tied the washing away of infants' original guilt to baptism. |
| 4. Free Will and Predestination | Conditional election God's election is open to all and is conditioned on faith, not fixed apart from the human response. Believers are elect according to the foreknowledge of God . God loved the world so that whoever believes may have life ; he does not wish that any should perish and takes no pleasure in the death of the wicked . The offer can be refused: Jesus longed to gather Jerusalem, but they were not willing , and people can resist the Holy Spirit . Whoever wishes may take the water of life . See . |
| 5. The Atonement | Penal substitution Christ's death saves by bearing, in our place, the penalty our sins deserved. Isaiah's servant was pierced for our transgressions as the LORD laid our iniquity on him ; it was the LORD's will to crush him . So God made him to be sin for us : he became a curse for us and bore our sins in his body , the righteous for the unrighteous . This shows God is just when he forgives , because without the shedding of blood there is no forgiveness . See . Wesley held penal substitution, reading as Christ bearing in our place the punishment for our iniquities. John Miley, H. Orton Wiley and much of the Holiness tradition taught the governmental theory instead, reading as Christ's death upholding God's justice as moral governor so that he can forgive. |
| 6. The Order of Salvation | Faith → regeneration Faith comes first, enabled by grace that goes before it, and God gives new life to those who believe. To all who received him he gave the right to become children of God ; by believing you may have life ; believers were sealed after they believed ; whoever believes has passed from death to life . |
| 7. Justification | Forensic, faith alone God declares sinners righteous by faith alone, apart from works. Paul says one is justified by faith apart from works of the law and that God justifies the ungodly , as when Abraham believed God and it was counted to him as righteousness . This righteousness comes from God and depends on faith , not on works of the law , because Christ's righteousness is credited to believers . So they have peace with God . See , and . |
| 8. Sanctification | Entire sanctification Wesleyans teach that God can make a believer perfect in love in this life. Paul prays that God would sanctify you completely , and Jesus commands be perfect as your heavenly Father is perfect . John says no one born of God makes a practice of sinning and perfect love casts out fear , so believers are urged to go on to maturity . This perfection means perfect love, not flawless behaviour. See . |
| 9. Baptism and the Lord's Supper | Covenant signs, spiritual presence Baptism is the covenant sign for believers and their children, and in the Supper believers truly feed on Christ by the Spirit, though not physically. Baptism replaces circumcision as the covenant sign . God's covenant always included children , so the promise is for you and for your children , and the children of a believer are holy . In the Supper the bread and cup are a participation in Christ's body and blood . See . Methodists baptize infants, since the promise is for you and for your children , and Article XVII of the Methodist Articles of Religion calls baptism a "sign of regeneration". The table is open, and the Supper, a real participation in Christ's body and blood , is a means of grace even for those still seeking faith. Nazarenes and Wesleyans also allow believer's baptism. |
| 10. Can Salvation Be Lost? | Lost and restored Believers can truly fall away, and the fallen can truly be restored. The warnings are meant seriously: those once enlightened can fall away , no sacrifice remains for wilful sin , the last state can become worse than the first , and some have fallen away from grace . Those who do not continue will be cut off , and a righteous person who turns away will die . Yet the lost son was dead and is alive again , whoever brings back a wanderer saves a soul , and the fallen are called to repent and do the works they did at first . |
| 11. The Unevangelized | Inclusivism Salvation comes only through Christ, but some may be saved by him without knowing his name if they respond to the light they have. Christ is the true light that enlightens everyone , so no one is wholly without light. God shows no partiality: in every nation whoever fears him is acceptable to him . Gentiles without the law show it written on their hearts . God made people to seek him and perhaps find him , and he rewards those who seek him . See . |
| 12. For Whom Did Christ Die? | For all, received by faith Christ died for every person, so salvation is open to all; it is received through faith, and those who are lost are lost by refusing it, not because no provision was made for them. John says Christ is the propitiation not for our sins only but for the sins of the whole world . God so loved the world that whoever believes will not perish ; he desires all people to be saved , and Christ gave himself as a ransom for all . By God's grace he tasted death for everyone and died for all , even for false teachers who deny him . Echoing , Article XX of the Methodist Articles of Religion calls Christ's offering "that perfect redemption, propitiation, and satisfaction for all the sins of the whole world, both original and actual". |
| 13. Can Grace Be Resisted? | Enabling, resistible God's grace goes first, because fallen people cannot turn to God by their own strength, and it reaches everyone: Christ, lifted up, draws all people ; the grace of God has appeared, bringing salvation to all ; the true light gives light to everyone . This grace frees the will to respond, but it can be refused. Stephen told his hearers, you always resist the Holy Spirit , and Jesus said of Jerusalem, I would have gathered you, and you were not willing . See . Article VIII of the Methodist Articles of Religion teaches that without the grace of God by Christ going before us ("preventing us") we cannot turn to God. That grace has appeared to all people , but it can be refused, as Stephen told his hearers that they always resist the Holy Spirit . |
| 14. The Afterlife and Final Destiny | Heaven / eternal hell The righteous enter eternal life, and the wicked suffer conscious punishment that never ends. Jesus sets the two side by side: they will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life . He sends the wicked into the eternal fire prepared for the devil , where their worm does not die and the fire is not quenched . Revelation says they will be tormented day and night forever and the smoke of their torment goes up forever . Paul calls it eternal destruction away from the presence of the Lord . Wesley's sermon "Of Hell" teaches eternal punishment and takes as its text Jesus' words that their worm does not die and the fire is not quenched . Many mainline Methodists today hold hopeful or annihilationist views. |
Official documents and key works
The Articles of Religion of the Methodist Church (United Methodist Church (from Wesley, 1784), 1784); A Plain Account of Christian Perfection (John Wesley, 1766); Arminian Theology: Myths and Realities (Roger E. Olson, 2006)