Soteriology Compared Support
3 of 14 · Foundations · Hamartiology

Original Sin and Human Nature

What did humanity inherit from Adam?

Inherited guilt and total depravity

Argument

Every person inherits Adam's guilt and a nature corrupted throughout. In Adam all die , and by one man's disobedience the many were made sinners , so David confesses he was brought forth in iniquity . Fallen people are therefore dead in trespasses and sins and by nature children of wrath . The heart is deceitful above all things , and no one seeks God . See and .

Objection

The Orthodox and those who hold personal guilt only object that the son shall not suffer for the iniquity of the father , so holding babies guilty for Adam's sin seems unjust.

Response

Paul sets Adam beside Christ: condemnation came through one man's trespass as righteousness comes through one man's act . If being condemned through one man is unjust, so is being saved through Christ's righteousness. Ezekiel addresses personal accountability within Israel, not the fall of the race.

Reformed: Reformed theology calls Adam humanity's covenant head, who represented the whole race, just as Christ is head of the redeemed .

Lutheran: Lutherans ground inherited sin in natural descent rather than in a covenant of representation: since the fall all are born with sin, as David says he was sinful from conception .

Anglican: Article IX teaches that every person is born "very far gone from original righteousness" and deserving God's wrath, because sin entered the world through one man and we are sinful from conception ; evangelicals read this as total depravity, Anglo-Catholics as a wounded nature.

Original sin washed away in baptism; nature wounded

Argument

Adam's descendants inherit the loss of original holiness, not a totally corrupted nature. Sin came to all through one man , and baptism washes this original sin away , though concupiscence remains: an inclination to sin that is not itself sin. Because nature is wounded rather than destroyed, people can still know and do natural good; even Gentiles show the law written on their hearts .

Objection

Reformed critics say Scripture calls people dead, not merely wounded . Orthodox critics say guilt cannot be inherited at all.

Response

First, dead refers to the loss of the supernatural life of grace, not the destruction of reason and will (Catechism 405–406). Second, original sin is called sin only by analogy: it is a state contracted, not an act committed, and it is not a personal fault in Adam's descendants (Catechism 404–405).

Inherited mortality and corruption, not guilt

Argument

Humanity inherits death and a corrupted nature from Adam, but not his guilt. In Greek, Romans 5:12 says death spread to all because all sinned (eph' hō) : each person then sins personally, and the soul who sins shall die . Augustine's reading relied on a Latin rendering, in whom. See .

Objection

Western critics, Catholic and Protestant, say Ps 51:5 and Eph 2:3 point to a sinful condition from birth, not only mortality .

Response

The inclination to sin is inherited and needs healing, but guilt is personal. Eph 2:3 describes a life lived according to the flesh.

Fallen, but enabled by prevenient grace

Argument

People are truly fallen and cannot turn to God on their own, but God's grace restores the ability to respond. This reaches everyone: the grace of God has appeared bringing salvation to all people , Christ draws all people to himself , and he enlightens everyone . So God commands all people everywhere to repent .

Objection

Reformed critics say prevenient grace is never named in Scripture; it looks like a construct built to protect free will, and Scripture calls the unregenerate dead .

Response

Dead means separated from God, which is why grace must come first: the grace that has appeared to all and Christ's drawing of all people enable the dead to respond. Since God also commands all to repent , the doctrine is no more inferential than the Reformed effectual call. Many in this group also hold that children are covered by Christ's atonement until they can choose.

Methodist / Wesleyan: Nazarenes and many Methodists hold that Christ's atonement covers children before they can choose, since the kingdom belongs to little children ; Wesley himself tied the washing away of infants' original guilt to baptism.

Personal guilt only

Argument

Each person bears guilt only for his own sins, not for Adam's. The soul who sins shall die, and the son shall not suffer for the iniquity of the father . Little children are therefore not condemned: Jesus said the kingdom belongs to them . At judgment each person receives what is due for what he has done . See .

Objection

Defenders of inherited guilt say Romans 5 ties all humanity's condemnation directly to Adam's one act .

Response

Adam brought death and a world where sin comes easily, and then everyone sins personally: death spread to all because all sinned .

Latter-day Saints: The second Article of Faith says people will be punished for their own sins and not for Adam's transgression. Latter-day Saints teach that Christ's Atonement answers for the Fall, so little children need no baptism (Moroni 8), in line with the principle that the son shall not bear the iniquity of the father .