Shared biblical foundations
Almost every tradition on this site agrees on these points. The debates are about how they fit together.
- Everyone has sinned and needs saving. All have sinned and fall short of the glory of God , and the wages of sin is death .
- God takes the initiative out of love.
- Christ's death and resurrection are the basis of salvation.
- Salvation is by grace.
- Faith and repentance are required.
- A real change of life follows.
Where each debate fits
is the umbrella over most of the fourteen debates. The first three are its foundations and the last is where it ends. Debates 12 and 13 take up two questions behind the Calvinist–Arminian debate; see Systems of salvation.
| # | Debate | Branch of theology | Role in salvation |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The Nature of God | Theology proper | Foundation: who saves |
| 2 | Authority | Bibliology | Foundation: how we know about salvation |
| 3 | Original Sin | The problem: why we need saving | |
| 4 | Free Will and Predestination | Soteriology | Who is saved, and why |
| 5 | The Atonement | Soteriology | The provision: what Christ did |
| 6 | Order of Salvation | Soteriology | The sequence: new birth and faith |
| 7 | Justification | Soteriology | How a sinner becomes right with God |
| 8 | Sanctification | Soteriology | How believers grow holy |
| 9 | Baptism and the Lord's Supper | Soteriology / sacraments | The means through which salvation is received |
| 10 | Can Salvation Be Lost? | Soteriology | Whether salvation is kept |
| 11 | The Unevangelized | Soteriology | The scope of salvation |
| 12 | For Whom Did Christ Die? | Soteriology | The extent of the atonement |
| 13 | Can Grace Be Resisted? | Soteriology | Whether God's call can be refused |
| 14 | The Afterlife | The completion: where salvation ends |
How the cross saves: theories of the atonement
Most traditions combine several of these. They differ on which one is central. See debate 5 for the arguments.
- : Christ bore the penalty for sin in our place . Central to Reformed and most evangelical theology.
- : Christ defeated sin, death and the devil . Strong in Orthodoxy.
- : Christ gave his life as a ransom for many .
- (Anselm): Christ's obedience restores God's honour.
- Moral influence (Abelard): the cross reveals God's love and moves people to repentance .
- (Grotius): the cross upholds God's moral order . Common among Arminians.
- (Irenaeus): Christ relives the human story faithfully as the new Adam .
The order of salvation
The as Reformed theology usually sets it out, built on the golden chain of :
- Election
- Calling
- (new birth)
- Faith and repentance
- Adoption
- Glorification
Arminians usually place faith before regeneration. Catholics and Orthodox see salvation as a lifelong, sacramental process rather than a sequence of steps. See debate 6.
The questions that divide the traditions
- Who takes the first step? God alone () or God and the person together ().
- For whom did Christ die? The elect, or everyone ().
- Can salvation be lost? See the deep dive.
- Is justification declared or infused? ( or )
- What do the sacraments do? , or symbols.