Does new birth come before faith, after it, or through baptism? Is salvation an event or a process?
Anglican: The Prayer Book links the new birth to baptism: the rite for infants opens with Christ's words that no one enters the kingdom unless born of water and the Spirit and then declares the child "regenerate." Anglo-Catholics take this as baptismal regeneration; evangelicals read it covenantally, as a sign and pledge of a new birth received by faith.
Baptist: Baptists are divided. Reformed Baptists teach that regeneration comes first and produces faith (1689 Confession ch. 10), because everyone who believes has been born of God . Most other Baptists teach that faith comes first and new life follows, since by believing we have life in his name . Both sides treat conversion as a definite event, followed by lifelong sanctification.
Quaker: For Friends, salvation is an inward process with no fixed order: the Light that enlightens everyone works in the heart and leads to the new birth without which no one can see the kingdom of God .
Latter-day Saints: Latter-day Saints teach that a person is born again by faith in Christ, repentance and baptism of water and of the Spirit, as Jesus tells Nicodemus . The order is faith, repentance, baptism by immersion by priesthood authority, then the gift of the Holy Ghost by the laying on of hands (Article of Faith 4), as Peter teaches at Pentecost ; rebirth then continues as a lifelong process of enduring to the end.
Jehovah's Witnesses: Salvation is a process, not a single event: a person studies the Bible, dedicates himself to Jehovah, then is baptized as the public symbol of that dedication, as Jesus commanded his followers to make disciples and baptize them . Being born again, which Jesus links to seeing the Kingdom of God , applies only to the 144,000 anointed who will rule in heaven, not to the majority who have an earthly hope.
Regeneration comes first and produces faith, because the spiritually dead cannot believe . New birth is God's act, not of the will of the flesh , and without it no one can see the kingdom . John writes that everyone who believes has been born of God , so believing is the sign of a birth already given. God promises a new heart , and the Lord opened Lydia's heart so that she paid attention . See and .
Objection
Wesleyan and other Arminian critics answer that Scripture puts faith first: believing leads to life , the Spirit is received by hearing with faith , and believers were sealed after they believed .
Response
The order is logical, not chronological: regeneration and faith happen in the same moment, the way a baby's birth and first breath coincide. So verses that link life and the Spirit to believing do not describe a gap in time.
Faith comes first, enabled by grace that goes before it, and God gives new life to those who believe. To all who received him he gave the right to become children of God ; by believing you may have life ; believers were sealed after they believed ; whoever believes has passed from death to life .
Objection
Reformed critics object that if unregenerate people can believe, calling them dead loses its force.
Response
Prevenient grace enables the dead will to respond. Dead describes separation from God, not inability to hear: the dead will hear the voice of the Son of God .
Mennonite: Mennonites hold no fixed order. Grace frees the will to respond (Hubmaier), so that all who receive Christ are given the right to become children of God , and the new birth shows itself in discipleship, because anyone in Christ is a new creation .
Salvation is a lifelong journey of growing into Christ , not a chain of logical steps. This is why Scripture speaks of it in three tenses: we have been saved , we are being saved , and salvation is nearer now than when we first believed . It is also why the one who endures to the end will be saved .
Objection
Protestant critics object that this makes assurance impossible and blurs justification with sanctification, since Scripture says the believer has eternal life now .
Response
On assurance, Scripture offers hope, not presumption: even Paul disciplined himself lest he be disqualified and pressed on toward the goal . On justification, salvation has both a real beginning and a lifelong course; the two traditions describe this in their own terms.
Catholic: Catholics hold that justification is truly given at baptism, the washing of regeneration , and then grows, so salvation has both a beginning and a lifelong course.
Orthodox: The Orthodox call a fixed ordo salutis a later scholastic construct; salvation is one journey in which believers are being saved .
New birth happens through baptism, as Jesus says no one can enter the kingdom unless born of water and the Spirit . The apostles tie baptism to forgiveness: repent and be baptized for the forgiveness of sins ; be baptized and wash away your sins . Peter says baptism now saves you . Paul says God saved us by the washing of regeneration and that all who were baptized into Christ have put on Christ . See .
Objection
Baptists and other critics object on three points. The thief on the cross was saved without baptism . Paul says Christ did not send him to baptize but to preach . And requiring baptism adds a work to faith .
Response
On the thief, the holders answer in different ways (see each tradition's note). In 1 Corinthians 1 Paul's point is who baptized, not whether to baptize. Nor is baptism a work added to faith: it is God's work, not a human one, for believers were raised with Christ through faith in the powerful working of God .
Lutheran: On the thief on the cross , Lutherans say baptism is ordinarily necessary but not absolutely necessary: whoever believes and is baptized will be saved , yet the same verse names only unbelief as what condemns. So it is contempt for baptism, not its lack, that condemns. In adults the Word creates faith before baptism.
Churches of Christ: On the thief on the cross , Churches of Christ answer that he died before the command to be baptized into Christ's death had been given or preached, and before the New Covenant began at Pentecost, when Peter preached repent and be baptized .
Oneness Pentecostal: The new birth is being born of water and of the Spirit, as Jesus says : repentance, baptism in Jesus' name and receiving the Holy Ghost with speaking in tongues, all three together, as Peter preached . Baptism alone is not the whole new birth. On the thief on the cross , Oneness Pentecostals answer that he died before the New Covenant took effect at Pentecost.