Soteriology Compared Support
2 of 14 · Foundations · Bibliology

Authority: Scripture and Tradition

Where does final authority in matters of faith come from?

Scripture alone (sola scriptura)

Argument

Scripture alone is the final authority, because only Scripture is breathed out by God and it equips the believer for every good work , written by men carried along by the Holy Spirit . Jesus treated it this way: he answered temptation with Scripture and judged human tradition by it . The Bereans did the same, testing even Paul's preaching against the Scriptures . See .

Objection

Catholic and Orthodox critics object that the Bible never teaches sola scriptura, that Paul tells believers to hold to oral traditions too , and that the church itself settled the canon. Thousands of Protestant denominations, they add, show that Scripture alone cannot settle disputes.

Response

Sola scriptura does not reject tradition; it makes Scripture the final judge of tradition. The church recognised the canon rather than creating it. Disagreement also exists among churches that appeal to tradition.

Adventist: Adventists hold to Scripture alone as the standard by which every teaching is tested, to the law and to the testimony . Ellen G. White's writings are received as a manifestation of the prophetic gift and speak with prophetic authority, yet they stay subordinate to Scripture and are tested by it, since all Scripture is breathed out by God (Fundamental Beliefs 1 and 18).

Scripture, Tradition and Magisterium

Argument

Authority rests on Scripture and apostolic Tradition together, interpreted by the church's teaching office (). Paul tells believers to hold the traditions taught by spoken word or by letter and to entrust that teaching to faithful men . The church is the pillar and buttress of the truth : Jesus gave Peter the keys and the power to bind and loose , and the Spirit guides the church into all truth .

Objection

Protestants object that unwritten traditions cannot be verified and have produced doctrines absent from Scripture, such as the later Marian dogmas. Jesus condemned traditions that make void the word of God .

Response

Tradition is not new revelation but the living transmission of the same apostolic deposit. The Magisterium serves the word of God and is not above it (Dei Verbum 10). Doctrine develops as a seed grows into a tree (Newman).

Holy Tradition

Argument

Final authority lies in , whose heart is Scripture, born inside the church. The Fathers and the Ecumenical Councils read Scripture with the mind of the church. They follow the council of Jerusalem, which decided as it seemed good to the Holy Spirit and to us , and they trust that the Spirit leads the church into all truth .

Objection

Protestant critics object that the Fathers and councils sometimes disagree with each other, so Tradition is not a single clear voice.

Response

The church receives the consensus of the Fathers, not every individual opinion, and a council's authority is confirmed by its reception across the whole church over time. There is no single office like the papacy.

Scripture first, read with tradition, reason and experience

Argument

Scripture is the primary authority, but it is not read alone: the church's tradition and sound reason help interpret it (), and so does the Spirit's witness in the believer . This is the careful reading Paul asks for when he says to test everything and hold fast what is good .

Objection

Critics who hold to Scripture alone object that reason and experience are subjective and can be used to override clear Scripture.

Response

The sources are not equal: Scripture judges the others.

Methodist / Wesleyan: Wesley added experience, the Spirit bearing witness with our spirit , to Scripture, tradition and reason, yet called himself a man of one book.

Anglican: Anglicans speak of three sources, Scripture, tradition and reason, with Scripture primary as the God-breathed word .

Bible plus modern revelation

Argument

God still speaks through living prophets, so the Bible is joined by modern revelation. God does nothing without revealing his secret to his servants the prophets , and Christ gave apostles and prophets to build up the church , so the church should still have them. The world could not contain all that could be written , and nothing in the Bible says revelation has stopped.

Objection

Other Christians object that the faith was delivered to the saints once for all , that even an angel preaching another gospel is accursed , that God has spoken finally in his Son , and that nothing is to be added to the prophecy .

Response

Once for all describes the faith's lasting reliability, not the end of revelation. God now speaks by his Son , and the risen Christ still speaks through the apostles and prophets he calls . Galatians forbids a different gospel , and restored revelation teaches the same one. Revelation 22:18 refers only to that book.

Bible as taught by the Governing Body

Argument

The Bible is the authority, and Jesus provides its right understanding through the Governing Body, the faithful and wise servant he appointed to give the household food at the proper time . This follows the first-century pattern, when the church had a central body in Jerusalem .

Objection

Other Christians object that the organisation has changed teachings and dates over time (for example on 1914 and 1975), and Scripture warns that a prophet whose word does not come to pass has spoken presumptuously .

Response

The path of the righteous is like the light of dawn that shines brighter until full day : understanding is refined gradually. The Governing Body is neither inspired nor infallible and does not claim to prophesy.

The Inner Light

Argument

Final authority is the Spirit of Christ teaching believers inwardly (). He is the true light that gives light to everyone , so every person can receive it. The anointing teaches believers directly , as in the new covenant, where God writes his law on hearts .

Objection

Protestant critics object that inner leadings cannot be tested and may contradict Scripture; believers are told to test the spirits .

Response

Robert Barclay taught that the Spirit never contradicts Scripture, and leadings are tested by the gathered meeting, as Paul says the others should weigh what prophets say . Barclay calls Scripture a secondary rule, subordinate to the Spirit; Evangelical Friends treat Scripture as the final outward authority.