Baptism regenerates; bread and wine truly become Christ
Argument
Baptism truly regenerates, and the bread and wine truly become Christ's body and blood. Baptism now saves you . It is God's work, not only a sign, so infants receive it too, as whole households were baptized . In the Supper Jesus said this is my body and unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man you have no life in you , for his flesh is true food . The cup is a participation in his blood , and eating unworthily makes one guilty of the body and blood . That guilt only makes sense if Christ is truly there.
Objection
Many Protestant critics say Jesus spoke figuratively, as when he called himself the door , and that he said the flesh is of no avail . Baptists add that the household baptisms never mention infants.
Response
Many disciples left over these words , and Jesus did not soften them into a metaphor. John 6:63 contrasts human understanding with the Spirit, not with Christ's flesh, and the early church took the realism at face value: Ignatius and Justin Martyr call the Eucharist the flesh of Jesus Christ. A household normally included its children.
Catholic: Catholics call this change transubstantiation: because Christ said over the bread this is my body , the Church teaches that the whole substance of the bread and wine becomes his body and blood, while their appearances remain (Council of Trent; Catechism 1376). That is why Catholics take literally his words that his flesh is true food and his blood true drink .
Orthodox: The Orthodox teach that in the Divine Liturgy, when the Holy Spirit is invoked, the bread and wine truly become Christ's body and blood, because the Lord himself said this is my body . How this happens is left a mystery, without a philosophical definition (some later texts, such as the Confession of Dositheus, use the word metousiosis). Infants too are baptized by triple immersion, because no one can enter the kingdom of God without being born of water and the Spirit ; they are chrismated at once and receive Communion from then on.