Soteriology Compared Support
9 of 14 · Soteriology · Sacraments

Baptism and the Lord's Supper

Who should be baptized, and what happens in baptism and communion?

Baptism regenerates; bread and wine truly become Christ

Argument

Baptism truly regenerates, and the bread and wine truly become Christ's body and blood. Baptism now saves you . It is God's work, not only a sign, so infants receive it too, as whole households were baptized . In the Supper Jesus said this is my body and unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man you have no life in you , for his flesh is true food . The cup is a participation in his blood , and eating unworthily makes one guilty of the body and blood . That guilt only makes sense if Christ is truly there.

Objection

Many Protestant critics say Jesus spoke figuratively, as when he called himself the door , and that he said the flesh is of no avail . Baptists add that the household baptisms never mention infants.

Response

Many disciples left over these words , and Jesus did not soften them into a metaphor. John 6:63 contrasts human understanding with the Spirit, not with Christ's flesh, and the early church took the realism at face value: Ignatius and Justin Martyr call the Eucharist the flesh of Jesus Christ. A household normally included its children.

Catholic: Catholics call this change transubstantiation: because Christ said over the bread this is my body , the Church teaches that the whole substance of the bread and wine becomes his body and blood, while their appearances remain (Council of Trent; Catechism 1376). That is why Catholics take literally his words that his flesh is true food and his blood true drink .

Orthodox: The Orthodox teach that in the Divine Liturgy, when the Holy Spirit is invoked, the bread and wine truly become Christ's body and blood, because the Lord himself said this is my body . How this happens is left a mystery, without a philosophical definition (some later texts, such as the Confession of Dositheus, use the word metousiosis). Infants too are baptized by triple immersion, because no one can enter the kingdom of God without being born of water and the Spirit ; they are chrismated at once and receive Communion from then on.

Baptism regenerates; Christ present in, with and under

Argument

Lutherans teach that Christ's body and blood are truly present in, with and under the bread and wine, and that baptism truly forgives sins. They take this is my body and this is my blood of the covenant, poured out for the forgiveness of sins at face value, without a philosophical explanation of how (). Baptism likewise gives the forgiveness it promises and saves through the washing of new birth . Word and sacrament are , the ways God gives grace.

Objection

Reformed critics say Christ's glorified body is a true human body, now in heaven at God's right hand until he returns, so it cannot be locally present on many altars at once; Jesus said do this in remembrance of me . They still hold that believers truly feed on Christ in the Supper, by the Spirit rather than bodily.

Response

Lutherans rest on Christ's words, 'This is my body': he is almighty and truthful. Because his divine and human natures are united in one person, he can be present as he promises, and God's right hand means his power, which is everywhere. Remembering Christ does not rule out his presence.

Covenant signs; spiritual presence

Argument

Baptism is the covenant sign for believers and their children, and in the Supper believers truly feed on Christ by the Spirit, though not physically. Baptism replaces circumcision as the covenant sign . God's covenant always included children , so the promise is for you and for your children , and the children of a believer are holy . In the Supper the bread and cup are a participation in Christ's body and blood . See .

Objection

Baptists say the New Covenant is with people who all know the Lord , so its sign belongs to believers only, and baptism pictures a believer's burial with Christ . Catholics say that this is my body speaks of what the bread itself becomes, so a presence given by the Spirit to believers, without a change in the bread and wine, falls short of Jesus' words.

Response

To Baptists: God has always included children in his covenant , and whole households were baptized . To Catholics: Christ is really present, though the bread and wine are not changed: by the Spirit believers truly feed on him through faith.

Reformed: Sacraments are signs and seals of the covenant of grace, as Paul calls circumcision a seal of the righteousness of faith , and effectual means of grace, and baptism now stands where circumcision stood as the covenant sign, as Paul links the two (Westminster Confession 27.1, 28.1). Grace is not so tied to baptism that all the baptized are regenerated: Simon the magician was baptized yet was later found still in the gall of bitterness (Acts 8:23; Westminster Confession 28.5–6).

Methodist / Wesleyan: Methodists baptize infants, since the promise is for you and for your children , and Article XVII of the Methodist Articles of Religion calls baptism a "sign of regeneration". The table is open, and the Supper, a real participation in Christ's body and blood , is a means of grace even for those still seeking faith. Nazarenes and Wesleyans also allow believer's baptism.

Believer's baptism; memorial supper

Argument

Baptism is for those who already believe, and the Supper is a remembrance of Christ's death. Every baptism in Acts follows faith: those who received the word were baptized , and when they believed they were baptized . Baptism pictures burial and resurrection with Christ , which is why most holders immerse. Jesus gave the Supper in remembrance of me , and it proclaims the Lord's death until he comes . See , and .

Objection

Churches that baptize infants say the household baptisms probably included children, and that infant baptism is attested by the 2nd–3rd century. Sacramental churches add that John 6 suggests more than remembrance .

Response

The household texts never mention infants, and they say the household believed . Later practice does not bind Scripture. Many in this view read John 6 as speaking of faith in Christ rather than of the Supper.

Baptist: Baptists hold that immersion is what baptism is, not just a fitting choice, because baptism pictures burial and resurrection with Christ (Baptist Faith and Message VII). Particular Baptists (1689 Confession 30.7) hold that worthy receivers feed on Christ spiritually in the Supper, not a bare memorial, reading the cup and bread as a participation in Christ's blood and body .

Mennonite: Most Mennonites baptize by pouring (Mennonite Brethren immerse). The Supper is also a sharing in Christ's body and blood that renews the covenant of the gathered church , and many congregations practise foot-washing, as Jesus told his disciples to wash one another's feet (Confession of Faith 1995, arts. 11–13).

Pentecostal: Water baptism is for believers, by immersion, because it pictures burial and resurrection with Christ , and the Lord's Supper is a memorial that proclaims the Lord's death until he comes (AG Fundamental Truth 6). Some Pentecostal churches, for example the Church of God (Cleveland), also practise foot-washing as an ordinance, following Jesus' command to wash one another's feet .

Adventist: Adventists baptize believers by immersion, because baptism pictures burial and rising with Christ . Foot-washing, the ordinance of humility that Jesus commanded , comes before the Lord's Supper, which proclaims the Lord's death until he comes , and Christ is present there to meet and strengthen his people (Fundamental Beliefs 15–16).

Believer's baptism necessary for salvation

Argument

A believer's baptism is necessary for salvation, because it is when sins are forgiven. Jesus said whoever believes and is baptized will be saved . Peter preached baptism for the forgiveness of sins , Paul was told to be baptized and wash away his sins , and one must be born of water and the Spirit . Even people who already believed were then baptized in Jesus' name .

Objection

Most other Protestants say Mark 16:16 condemns only unbelief, not a lack of baptism. They point out that the thief on the cross was saved without baptism , that Paul was not sent to baptize , and that Jesus commanded baptism in the name of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit .

Response

An unbeliever would not be baptized, so condemning unbelief alone is natural, and the promise is attached to believing and being baptized. The thief lived before the New Covenant took effect. Paul still baptized (1 Cor 1:14-16); his point was that the Corinthians must not divide over who baptized them, not that baptism is unnecessary. Matt 28:19 is itself Christ's command to baptize, so it does not break the link between baptism and forgiveness, though holders differ over the words used in baptism (see the notes).

Churches of Christ: Churches of Christ immerse penitent believers, usually saying the words Christ commanded, in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit , and read "in the name of Jesus Christ" in Acts as meaning by his authority, not as a different formula.

Oneness Pentecostal: Oneness Pentecostals baptize by immersion and in the name of Jesus, as in every baptism in Acts where the name is recorded (Acts 2:38; 10:48), including the Samaritans baptized into the name of the Lord Jesus and disciples who were rebaptized in the name of the Lord Jesus . They read the singular "name" in Matt 28:19 as Jesus. Water baptism is one part of the one new birth, together with repentance and receiving the Holy Ghost, because a person must be born of water and of the Spirit .

Priesthood ordinances, including for the dead

Argument

Latter-day Saints teach that baptism and other ordinances are valid only when performed by priesthood authority, and that saving ordinances such as baptism can also be performed by proxy for those who have died. Authority must come from God: no one takes the honour for himself but is called by God . Baptism for the dead lets those who died without the gospel receive its ordinances, since the gospel was preached even to the dead , and they remain free to accept or reject what is done for them. The weekly sacrament, with bread and water, renews covenants.

Objection

Other Christians say 1 Cor 15:29 is one obscure verse, and Paul says "they", not "we", practise it. Proxy salvation also clashes with judgment after death .

Response

Paul uses the practice as evidence for the resurrection without condemning it. The dead still choose to accept or reject what is done for them .

No outward sacraments

Argument

Quakers hold that baptism and communion are inward realities, so outward rites are not needed. There is one baptism , and it is the baptism with the Holy Spirit and fire , not water. True communion is inward fellowship with Christ, who stands at the door and knocks . Outward forms were a shadow of the things to come . See .

Objection

Most other churches say Jesus commanded both baptism and the Supper , and that the apostles practised them after Pentecost .

Response

Barclay notes that the Great Commission never mentions water: to baptize into the name is to bring people into Christ's power by the Spirit . Breaking bread was a figure the early church kept for a time, like foot-washing; "until he comes" means his inward coming , when the shadow gives way to substance .