Soteriology Compared Support
1 of 14 · Foundations · Theology proper

The Nature of God

Is God one being in three persons?

Nicene Trinity

Argument

Scripture insists there is one God , yet it calls the Father, the Son and the Spirit God , and it names all three together in one baptismal name and one blessing . Only one being in three persons () holds all of these texts together.

Objection

Oneness Pentecostals and Jehovah's Witnesses object that the word Trinity never appears in the Bible, and that the formula came from 4th-century councils that borrowed Greek philosophical terms.

Response

The word is a summary term, like the word Bible itself. Nicaea did not invent the doctrine; it defended what the apostles already practised: Jesus received worship , is called God , and the church baptized in one name of three.

Churches of Christ: Churches of Christ are Trinitarian in substance but state it in biblical rather than creedal language: Christ commands baptism into the one name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit , and John says the Word was God . Barton W. Stone questioned the creedal formulas.

Oneness (modalism)

Argument

God is absolutely one person, fully revealed in Jesus; Father, Son and Spirit are titles or manifestations of that one God (). Jesus says this himself: he and the Father are one , and whoever has seen him has seen the Father . Paul agrees, since all the fullness of deity dwells in him bodily . Isaiah even calls the promised child Everlasting Father .

Objection

Trinitarians object that Jesus prays to the Father and speaks of the glory he had with the Father before the world existed . At his baptism the Father speaks from heaven while the Spirit descends . Jesus also promises another Helper .

Response

The prayers show Jesus' real human nature speaking to God, and the glory 'before the world was' (John 17:5) existed in God's plan and foreknowledge. The baptism shows an omnipresent God manifesting in several ways at once, not three persons. The 'other Helper' is Christ himself in Spirit: 'I will come to you' (John 14:18). The one God says he is the first and the last, with no other beside him .

Three separate beings (the Godhead)

Argument

The Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit are three distinct beings, one in purpose rather than in substance. At Jesus' baptism they appear as distinct , and Stephen sees the Son standing at God's right hand . Jesus prayed that his disciples would be one as he and the Father are one , which is a unity of purpose, not of substance. Latter-day Saints read Joseph Smith's First Vision as confirming this.

Objection

Trinitarian and Oneness critics object that Scripture says there is only one God, with none formed before or after him , which rules out three Gods.

Response

Latter-day Saints speak of one Godhead united in purpose and will. They read the Isaiah texts as rejecting idols, not the distinct members of the Godhead.

The Father alone is God

Argument

The Father alone is the one true God, and the Son is his first creation. Jesus called the Father the only true God and said the Father is greater than he . The Son is the firstborn of all creation and the beginning of God's creation ; Witnesses read the wisdom brought forth at the beginning as the Son. So Paul says that for us there is one God, the Father .

Objection

Trinitarians object that John calls the Word God , Thomas calls Jesus my Lord and my God , and all things were created through him , so he cannot himself be created.

Response

The New World Translation renders John 1:1 as "a god," since there is no article before theos. Thomas's words are taken as an exclamation of honour. Firstborn is read as first-created, and Col 1:16 as all other things.