Soteriology Compared Support
14 of 14 · The End · Eschatology

The Afterlife and Final Destiny

What happens after death, and is hell eternal?

Heaven and eternal conscious punishment

Argument

The righteous enter eternal life, and the wicked suffer conscious punishment that never ends. Jesus sets the two side by side: they will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life . He sends the wicked into the eternal fire prepared for the devil , where their worm does not die and the fire is not quenched . Revelation says they will be tormented day and night forever and the smoke of their torment goes up forever . Paul calls it eternal destruction away from the presence of the Lord .

Objection

Annihilationists object that endless torment for finite sins seems disproportionate. Scripture often speaks of the lost being destroyed or perishing , and only God has immortality .

Response

Sin against an infinite God is infinitely serious. Only God has immortality in himself ; human immortality is his gift. Destruction means ruin, not ceasing to exist: eternal destruction away from the presence of the Lord .

Churches of Christ: The majority holds the traditional view that the wicked will go away into eternal punishment . A minority, following Edward Fudge (The Fire That Consumes, 1982), holds conditional immortality and reads God's power to destroy both soul and body in hell as final destruction, not endless torment.

Methodist / Wesleyan: Wesley's sermon "Of Hell" teaches eternal punishment and takes as its text Jesus' words that their worm does not die and the fire is not quenched . Many mainline Methodists today hold hopeful or annihilationist views.

Mennonite: The Dordrecht Confession (art. XVIII) teaches that at the judgment all the dead will rise, some to life and some to condemnation , and that the wicked go into eternal punishment . The 1995 Confession (art. 24) is more reserved.

Heaven, hell and purgatory

Argument

Catholics teach that those who die in God's grace but are not yet fully purified are cleansed after death, in purgatory, before entering heaven. Each one's work will be tested by fire , and some will suffer loss but be saved, only as through fire . Cleansing is needed because nothing unclean will enter heaven and without holiness no one will see the Lord . Judas Maccabeus offered prayer and sacrifice for the dead (2 Maccabees 12:46, in the Catholic canon), and the Church has prayed for the dead since its earliest days. See .

Objection

Protestants object that Christ's sacrifice cleanses completely, once for all , and that 2 Maccabees is not in the Protestant canon.

Response

Purgatory does not add to Christ's work; it is the final application of it, a purification before seeing God face to face (Catechism 1030–1032). Nor does it rest on 2 Maccabees alone: Paul speaks of being saved only as through fire , and the Church received Maccabees as Scripture long before the Reformation (councils of Hippo and Carthage; Trent, Session IV).

God's presence experienced as joy or torment

Argument

Orthodox teachers commonly describe heaven and hell as the same presence of God, experienced in two ways. Our God is a consuming fire : his presence is joy to those who love him and torment to those who hate him, as perfect love casts out fear . The Church prays for the departed.

Objection

Western critics object that this softens hell as punishment, and that hope for all can drift into universalism .

Response

The Church confesses an eternal judgment (Matt 25:46), so hell is not softened. It anathematised the Origenist doctrine of apokatastasis (anathemas associated with the Council of Constantinople, 553), while allowing prayerful hope that God's mercy is wide.

Annihilationism (conditional immortality)

Argument

The wicked are not tormented forever but finally destroyed, because humans are not naturally immortal. Only God has immortality . The soul who sins shall die , for the wages of sin is death , and the dead know nothing . So hell ends in destruction: God can destroy both soul and body in hell , and the wicked perish and vanish like smoke and will be burned up like stubble . See and .

Objection

Defenders of eternal punishment object that Matt 25:46 puts eternal punishment beside eternal life , and that the smoke of their torment goes up forever .

Response

Eternal punishment is eternal in its result, like the eternal fire that destroyed Sodom and Gomorrah , which is no longer burning. The rising smoke is imagery borrowed from Isaiah 34:10 (Edward Fudge).

Adventist: The dead sleep, unconscious, until the resurrection, because the dead know nothing . After the millennium the wicked are raised, judged and destroyed by fire, burned up like stubble , with punishment in proportion to their deeds (Fundamental Beliefs 26–27).

Three degrees of glory

Argument

Latter-day Saints teach that the resurrected receive different degrees of glory, not just heaven or hell. Paul says there is one glory of the sun, another of the moon and another of the stars . Jesus says in my Father's house are many rooms , and Paul knew a man caught up to the third heaven , so heaven has more than one level. See .

Objection

Other Christians object that 1 Corinthians 15 contrasts earthly and resurrected bodies, not levels of heaven, and that Jesus describes only two destinies .

Response

Latter-day Saints read Paul's contrast as degrees of resurrected glory, as revealed in Doctrine and Covenants 76. A few sons of perdition go to outer darkness (D&C 76:31–38). 'Eternal punishment' names God's punishment, not necessarily punishment without end (D&C 19:6–12).