Soteriology Compared Support
5 of 14 · Soteriology · Atonement

The Atonement

What did Christ's death accomplish, and how?

Penal substitution

Argument

Christ's death saves by bearing, in our place, the penalty our sins deserved. Isaiah's servant was pierced for our transgressions as the LORD laid our iniquity on him ; it was the LORD's will to crush him . So God made him to be sin for us : he became a curse for us and bore our sins in his body , the righteous for the unrighteous . This shows God is just when he forgives , because without the shedding of blood there is no forgiveness . See .

Objection

Critics, including nonviolent-atonement theologians, make three points: it pits the Father against the Son; punishing an innocent person for the guilty is unjust ; and forgiveness that demands payment is not really forgiveness.

Response

First, the Son is not a victim of the Father: he lays down his life of his own accord . Second, the penalty does not fall on an outsider, because God bears the cost himself (John Stott calls this self-substitution); Trinitarian holders add that the Father, Son and Spirit act together in it. Third, forgiveness is free to us because it was costly to him.

Oneness Pentecostal: Oneness Pentecostals do not describe the cross as something that happens between three persons. The one God, manifest in the flesh as the Son, was in Christ reconciling the world and paid the cost himself, because the church is the church of God which he purchased with his own blood .

Methodist / Wesleyan: Wesley held penal substitution, reading as Christ bearing in our place the punishment for our iniquities. John Miley, H. Orton Wiley and much of the Holiness tradition taught the governmental theory instead, reading as Christ's death upholding God's justice as moral governor so that he can forgive.

Satisfaction and merit

Argument

Christ's death makes superabundant for sin, because his perfect obedience and love were offered through the eternal Spirit as a fragrant offering to God . By that single offering he has perfected those being sanctified . Its merits reach believers through the sacraments, and the one sacrifice is made present in the Mass, which Jesus instituted when he said do this in remembrance of me .

Objection

Protestant critics object that re-presenting the sacrifice in the Mass seems to undermine Christ's offering once for all .

Response

The Mass does not repeat Calvary; it makes the one sacrifice present, as Jesus said do this in remembrance of me (anamnesis) (Catechism 1366–1367).

Christus Victor and recapitulation

Argument

Christ's death and resurrection are a victory that frees humanity and heals it. He died to destroy the one who has the power of death and to free those enslaved by fear of death . He disarmed the rulers and authorities and triumphed over them , giving his life as a ransom for many . As the last Adam he heals human nature from within , so that in Christ all will be made alive . See and .

Objection

Defenders of penal substitution say it describes what the cross achieved but not how guilt is dealt with, and that it sidelines the many sacrificial texts .

Response

Victory over the powers includes cancelling the record of debt by nailing it to the cross . Orthodoxy uses sacrificial language too, but reads it as healing rather than appeasing wrath.

Governmental

Hugo Grotius, many 19th-century Arminians and revivalists

Argument

The cross shows how seriously God takes sin, upholding his moral government while he forgives, so that he is both just and the justifier . See .

Objection

Defenders of penal substitution object that it does not do justice to Christ personally bearing our sins in his body .

Response

Christ suffered in place of the penalty, so the view is substitutionary even if it is not strictly penal.

Nonviolent atonement

J. Denny Weaver and other modern Mennonite theologians

Argument

God does not require violence. The powers of the world killed Jesus, and the resurrection defeats them . Jesus' nonviolent life, turning the other cheek and overcoming evil with good , is itself part of the atonement. See .

Objection

Defenders of penal substitution point out that Isaiah says it was the will of the LORD to crush him , and that the cross was God's definite plan .

Response

God's plan was to overcome evil by absorbing it, not by inflicting it. The crushing describes God giving his Son over to human violence.

Atonement in Gethsemane and on the cross

Argument

Christ's atonement began in Gethsemane and was completed on the cross. In the garden he suffered for sin so intensely that his sweat became like great drops of blood (D&C 19:16–18). The atonement guarantees resurrection to all, since in Christ all will be made alive , and it brings forgiveness to those who repent.

Objection

Other Christians object that Scripture ties atonement to his blood shed on the cross , not to the garden.

Response

Latter-day Saints affirm the cross too: Gethsemane began the atoning suffering and the cross finished it.

A ransom equal to Adam's lost life

Argument

Jesus gave his perfect human life as a corresponding ransom for all , exactly equal to the perfect life Adam lost; he came to give his life as a ransom for many . See .

Objection

Trinitarian critics object that only a divine saviour could bear the sins of the world, and that Acts 20:28 says God obtained the church with his own blood .

Response

Justice required an exact equivalent, a perfect man, not God. The New World Translation reads Acts 20:28 as with the blood of his own Son (2013 revision).