Soteriology Compared Support
8 of 14 · Soteriology · Sanctification

Sanctification

How do believers become holy after they are saved, and how far can it go in this life?

Progressive, never complete in this life

Argument

Believers grow in holiness throughout life but are never sinless before glory. Scripture warns that if we say we have no sin, we deceive ourselves . Paul describes wanting the good yet doing evil , and the flesh and the Spirit war against each other . So believers are being transformed from one degree of glory to another , pressing on because they are not yet perfect . See .

Objection

Wesleyans and Quakers object that this view can breed low expectations and does not take seriously the command to be perfect or the promise that one born of God does not keep on sinning .

Response

Holders answer that grace really does transform, so the expectation is real change; but perfection waits for glorification, because when he appears we shall be like him .

Lutheran: Lutherans call this : the believer is at the same time righteous in Christ and still a sinner, as Paul's struggle with sin shows.

Anglican: Article XV teaches that all Christians, though baptized and born again in Christ, still offend in many things, and it quotes John: if we say we have no sin, we deceive ourselves .

Churches of Christ: Believers are sanctified at conversion (1 Cor 6:11) and grow in holiness, being transformed from one degree of glory to another . Many read Paul's struggle in Romans 7 as life under the law, not the Christian life.

Adventist: Sanctification lasts a lifetime: the Spirit transforms believers by renewing their minds (Fundamental Belief 10), and Adventists stress victory over sin through his power. "Historic" Adventists also teach character perfection in the last generation.

Entire sanctification (Christian perfection)

Argument

Wesleyans teach that God can make a believer perfect in love in this life. Paul prays that God would sanctify you completely , and Jesus commands be perfect as your heavenly Father is perfect . John says no one born of God makes a practice of sinning and perfect love casts out fear , so believers are urged to go on to maturity . This perfection means perfect love, not flawless behaviour. See .

Objection

Reformed and Lutheran critics object that no saint has ever claimed to be sinless, and that John denies it outright: if we say we have no sin, we deceive ourselves .

Response

Wesleyans answer that Wesley defined perfection as freedom from wilful sin, not from mistakes, so it is no claim to be sinless. And the present tense in 1 John 3:9 describes not continuing in sin as a practice.

Lifelong transformation through grace and sacraments

Argument

Holiness grows over a whole life as grace works through prayer, fasting, the sacraments and virtue. Peter tells believers to add to faith virtue, knowledge and love , because without holiness no one will see the Lord . The goal is to become partakers of the divine nature .

Objection

Protestant critics object that this view puts the weight on human effort and ritual, though salvation is by grace, not by works .

Response

Holders answer that every step is cooperation enabled by grace , and the sacraments are Christ acting, not human achievement. Effort still has its place: even Paul disciplined his body .

Catholic: Catholics hold that purification may be completed after death (), pointing to the one who is saved, but only as through fire .

Discipleship in community

Argument

Mennonites hold that holiness is lived together in the church, by following Jesus daily . It includes mutual correction among members , nonresistance , and simplicity, refusing to be conformed to this world .

Objection

Critics from other Protestant traditions object that this can slide into legalism and external rules.

Response

Mennonites answer that church discipline aims at restoring the one who falls, in a spirit of gentleness , not at keeping rules for their own sake.

Eternal progression

Argument

Latter-day Saints teach that becoming perfect is a process that continues beyond this life. Jesus' command be perfect as your Father is perfect points to becoming like the Father, as heirs of God and fellow heirs with Christ , and John promises we shall be like him . See .

Objection

Other Christians object that humans can never become beings like God , because God is not a man .

Response

Latter-day Saints teach that exaltation is always by Christ's grace and under the Father, and point to Jesus quoting you are gods .