Is the sinner declared righteous, made righteous, or transformed?
Quaker: The sinner is made righteous, not only declared righteous. Remission of sins comes through Christ's outward sacrifice, and justification is being made righteous by Christ revealed within, since God saves us by the washing of regeneration and renewing of the Holy Spirit (Barclay, Prop. VII).
Oneness Pentecostal: Oneness Pentecostals teach that the sinner is forgiven and made a new creature through the new birth, by grace through obedient faith: repentance, baptism in Jesus' name for the remission of sins, and receiving the Holy Ghost with tongues , because no one enters the kingdom without being born of water and of the Spirit .
Jehovah's Witnesses: God counts a person righteous on the basis of faith in the ransom, and that faith must be shown by faithful obedience, because faith without works is dead ; full justification comes only after the final test at the end of the Thousand Years.
God declares sinners righteous by faith alone, apart from works. Paul says one is justified by faith apart from works of the law and that God justifies the ungodly , as when Abraham believed God and it was counted to him as righteousness . This righteousness comes from God and depends on faith , not on works of the law , because Christ's righteousness is credited to believers . So they have peace with God . See , and .
Objection
Catholic and other critics point out that James says a person is justified by works and not by faith alone , the only place the words faith alone appear in the Bible, and that God will render to each according to his works .
Response
James addresses a dead faith that only claims belief , and uses justified to mean shown to be righteous; Paul addresses how a sinner becomes right with God. Judgment by works weighs the fruit that true faith bears, not the ground of acceptance. Faith alone saves, but saving faith is never alone (Calvin).
Justification actually makes a person righteous (), because God's love is poured into the heart through the Holy Spirit . So what counts is faith working through love . This is why God gives eternal life to those who seek glory by patience in well-doing , and why a person is justified by works and not by faith alone : faith without works is dead .
Objection
Protestant critics reply that Paul excludes works of every kind , and that if righteousness is infused, no one can be sure they have enough.
Response
Paul excludes works of the law done to earn favour, not faith working through love . Trent condemns justification by works without grace (Session VI, canon 1); merit is itself God's gift. Assurance rests on God: without special revelation no one knows with certainty of faith that he is in grace, yet all should hope firmly in God's help (Session VI, chapters 9, 12–13).
Salvation is becoming partakers of the divine nature ; when Christ appears we shall be like him , and we are being transformed from one degree of glory to another . Justification is one aspect of union with Christ, which heals and transforms. See .
Objection
Protestant critics object that deification sounds like humans becoming God, and that it neglects Paul's legal language .
Response
Theosis means sharing in God's energies (his life and glory), never his essence. God became man so that man might become god (Athanasius, On the Incarnation 54): by grace, not by nature.
Faith means following Jesus, so it shows itself in obedience. Whoever would come after him must deny himself and take up his cross daily . Jesus says not everyone who says Lord, Lord will enter, but the one who does the Father's will , and James adds that faith apart from works is dead . See .
Objection
Lutheran and Reformed critics say it risks making salvation depend on performance and undermines assurance .
Response
Obedience is not payment but the shape of real faith, and grace itself trains us to live godly lives .
Churches of Christ: Justification (the forgiveness of sins) is God's free act, received by obedient faith when the believer is baptized into Christ, because all who were baptized into Christ have put on Christ (see also Gal 3:26; Rom 6:3-7). Churches of Christ reject "faith only," since James says a person is justified by works and not by faith alone .
Christ's grace is necessary and empowering, and the covenants of baptism and the temple bind people to him. That is why Paul says to work out your own salvation , Jesus says only those who do the Father's will enter , and the dead are judged by what they have done . The Book of Mormon says we are saved by grace, after all we can do (2 Nephi 25:23); Church leaders and teachers stress that grace is not a final top-up after a person's efforts but enabling power at every step.
Objection
Evangelical critics object that it adds requirements to the finished work of Christ .
Response
Latter-day Saints say covenants are a way of receiving, not earning, and that Christ's grace enables obedience at every step.