Mennonite
The Anabaptist movement of the 1520s; named after Menno Simons (1496–1561). Related groups include the Amish, Hutterites and Brethren.
Key figures: Menno Simons, Balthasar Hubmaier, Conrad Grebel, Harold Bender
Salvation is (Nachfolge): faith and obedience to Jesus cannot be separated. Mennonites practise , church discipline, nonresistance and simplicity. Traditionally salvation can be lost; the Amish speak of a 'living hope' rather than claiming certainty. Some modern Mennonites teach a .
Its position in each of the 14 debates
| Debate | Position and main argument |
|---|---|
| 1. The Nature of God | Trinity Scripture insists there is one God , yet it calls the Father, the Son and the Spirit God , and it names all three together in one baptismal name and one blessing . Only one being in three persons () holds all of these texts together. |
| 2. Authority: Scripture and Tradition | Scripture alone Scripture alone is the final authority, because only Scripture is breathed out by God and it equips the believer for every good work , written by men carried along by the Holy Spirit . Jesus treated it this way: he answered temptation with Scripture and judged human tradition by it . The Bereans did the same, testing even Paul's preaching against the Scriptures . See . |
| 3. Original Sin and Human Nature | Personal guilt only Each person bears guilt only for his own sins, not for Adam's. The soul who sins shall die, and the son shall not suffer for the iniquity of the father . Little children are therefore not condemned: Jesus said the kingdom belongs to them . At judgment each person receives what is due for what he has done . See . |
| 4. Free Will and Predestination | Conditional election God's election is open to all and is conditioned on faith, not fixed apart from the human response. Believers are elect according to the foreknowledge of God . God loved the world so that whoever believes may have life ; he does not wish that any should perish and takes no pleasure in the death of the wicked . The offer can be refused: Jesus longed to gather Jerusalem, but they were not willing , and people can resist the Holy Spirit . Whoever wishes may take the water of life . See . |
| 5. The Atonement | Mennonites teach that Christ's death and resurrection free people from sin and the powers of evil and reconcile them to God, and the 1995 Confession (art. 8) holds several images together: sacrifice, ransom (he came to give his life as a ransom for many ) and victory over the powers, which Christ disarmed and triumphed over on the cross . Some modern Mennonite theologians, such as J. Denny Weaver, teach a nonviolent atonement. |
| 6. The Order of Salvation | Faith → regeneration Faith comes first, enabled by grace that goes before it, and God gives new life to those who believe. To all who received him he gave the right to become children of God ; by believing you may have life ; believers were sealed after they believed ; whoever believes has passed from death to life . Mennonites hold no fixed order. Grace frees the will to respond (Hubmaier), so that all who receive Christ are given the right to become children of God , and the new birth shows itself in discipleship, because anyone in Christ is a new creation . |
| 7. Justification | Obedient faith Faith means following Jesus, so it shows itself in obedience. Whoever would come after him must deny himself and take up his cross daily . Jesus says not everyone who says Lord, Lord will enter, but the one who does the Father's will , and James adds that faith apart from works is dead . See . |
| 8. Sanctification | Discipleship in community Mennonites hold that holiness is lived together in the church, by following Jesus daily . It includes mutual correction among members , nonresistance , and simplicity, refusing to be conformed to this world . |
| 9. Baptism and the Lord's Supper | Ordinances (believers, memorial) Baptism is for those who already believe, and the Supper is a remembrance of Christ's death. Every baptism in Acts follows faith: those who received the word were baptized , and when they believed they were baptized . Baptism pictures burial and resurrection with Christ , which is why most holders immerse. Jesus gave the Supper in remembrance of me , and it proclaims the Lord's death until he comes . See , and . Most Mennonites baptize by pouring (Mennonite Brethren immerse). The Supper is also a sharing in Christ's body and blood that renews the covenant of the gathered church , and many congregations practise foot-washing, as Jesus told his disciples to wash one another's feet (Confession of Faith 1995, arts. 11–13). |
| 10. Can Salvation Be Lost? | Lost and restored Believers can truly fall away, and the fallen can truly be restored. The warnings are meant seriously: those once enlightened can fall away , no sacrifice remains for wilful sin , the last state can become worse than the first , and some have fallen away from grace . Those who do not continue will be cut off , and a righteous person who turns away will die . Yet the lost son was dead and is alive again , whoever brings back a wanderer saves a soul , and the fallen are called to repent and do the works they did at first . |
| 11. The Unevangelized | Mennonites have no single binding answer. Traditionally they held that salvation comes only through explicit faith in Christ, since there is no other name by which we must be saved ; many modern Mennonites are inclusivist and trust that in every nation God accepts anyone who fears him and does what is right . |
| 12. For Whom Did Christ Die? | For all, received by faith Christ died for every person, so salvation is open to all; it is received through faith, and those who are lost are lost by refusing it, not because no provision was made for them. John says Christ is the propitiation not for our sins only but for the sins of the whole world . God so loved the world that whoever believes will not perish ; he desires all people to be saved , and Christ gave himself as a ransom for all . By God's grace he tasted death for everyone and died for all , even for false teachers who deny him . |
| 13. Can Grace Be Resisted? | Yes, grace can be refused. Anabaptists teach that God, through his Word preached to all, restores the will's freedom to answer in faith and obedience, and that this call can be refused, just as Jesus wanted to gather Jerusalem but they were not willing (Balthasar Hubmaier, On the Freedom of the Will, 1527). Mennonites speak of yieldedness (Gelassenheit) and discipleship rather than Arminian categories. |
| 14. The Afterlife and Final Destiny | Heaven / eternal hell The righteous enter eternal life, and the wicked suffer conscious punishment that never ends. Jesus sets the two side by side: they will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life . He sends the wicked into the eternal fire prepared for the devil , where their worm does not die and the fire is not quenched . Revelation says they will be tormented day and night forever and the smoke of their torment goes up forever . Paul calls it eternal destruction away from the presence of the Lord . The Dordrecht Confession (art. XVIII) teaches that at the judgment all the dead will rise, some to life and some to condemnation , and that the wicked go into eternal punishment . The 1995 Confession (art. 24) is more reserved. |
Official documents and key works
Schleitheim Confession (Swiss Brethren, 1527); Dordrecht Confession of Faith (Dutch Mennonites, 1632); Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective (Mennonite Church USA / Mennonite Church Canada, 1995); On the Freedom of the Will (Balthasar Hubmaier, 1527)